Sunday, 1 July 2007

PREFACE




The meaning of life and other easy questions!

"Tomorrow and tomorrow and tomorrow creeps in this petty pace from day to day to the last syllable of recorded time and all our yesterdays have lighted fools the way to dusty death. Out, out brief candle! Life's but a walking shadow. A poor player that struts and frets his hour upon the stage until he is heard no more. It is a tale told by an idiot full of sound and fury signifying nothing."
Macbeth Act V Scene V.
I learnt this soliloquy from Macbeth by heart, at about the age of seven and used it as my "party piece" whenever my parents had the opportunity to show off their gifted children in front of an appreciative audience of family and friends. What my parents could never have predicted was the consequence of my sudden understanding of this bleak passage, when at about the age of eleven, I embarked on my lifelong career an insomniac. I remember clearly as a precocious young boy, lying awake all night trying to determine which was worse, to live forever, or to die at some uncertain point in the future and what was life all about anyway? Shakespeare's suggestion that it signified nothing added a new layer or terror to my troubled nights. However, with the passage of time my experience of life (and for that matter my experience of death), I think I've been able to define the questions with considerable more maturity than that of the pre-pubescent lad. I therefore welcomed the opportunity this memoir provides me with, to try to synthesize fifty years of self-questioning as to the meaning of life and the relevance of this to my clinical practice.
My attitude to the big question has been shaped by three major influences. These influences have been my upbringing as a Jew, my scientific curiosity as a practicing clinical scientist and my lifelong passionate affair with the visual arts. I don't think it’s any exaggeration or particular conceit to say that sometimes I have to draw on all these inner resources in counseling my patients to help them make difficult decisions that might influence both the length and quality of their lives.
In the quiet doldrums between Christmas and the end of the New Year holiday break in 1995, I was called in to help a young woman make one of the toughest choices that anyone can ever be called upon to decide.
In fact the decision reminded me of “Sophie’s choice” in William Styron’s tragic novel of the same name.
The young woman in question was a pretty Greek Orthodox girl aged thirty-one. Four years earlier she had been diagnosed with breast cancer at a time when she was twelve weeks pregnant. The pregnancy was terminated and she underwent a conventional course of treatment that involved surgery, radiotherapy and chemotherapy. She was very keen to start a family and I advised her to wait a year or two. It should be noted in passing that a pregnancy after breast cancer has been treated does not influence the prognosis, contrary to popular myth. At the time I was called in to advice, she was twenty -one weeks pregnant and had already felt the quickening of the baby in her womb. Tragically, she had also felt the symptoms of the secondary cancer in her spine. In addition to the severe pain that she experienced, she also described numbness and paresis affecting her left arm. Investigations demonstrated that there were metastases in the spine, compressing the spinal cord and the nerve roots to her left arm. The various therapeutic options we had to consider included surgery for immediate decompression of the spinal cord, radiotherapy to the vertebra and cytotoxic chemotherapy. To do nothing at that stage would have been unthinkable as without treatment she would have become paraplegic in about 48 hours. Yet, the most effective treatments to prevent this dreaded complication and to add to the length and quality to her remaining life, would compromise the health or viability of the baby in the womb. Whose life was of greater value and whose decision was it anyway? Was the potential life of the unborn more meaningful than prolonging the life of a young adult? I was hoping that her own religious beliefs would guide me in this tough decision, but when asked directly she confessed to being a lapsed Christian and asked me for all the facts so that she could make an informed choice. Amongst the difficult truths that I had to convey was the fact that with even the best of all treatments her expectation of life would be unlikely to exceed two years and therefore should she allow a new life into the world the baby would grow up motherless. There was clearly no correct answer to this dilemma and I will return to the conclusion of this sad story at the end of the chapter but first let me tell what influenced my advice.
Judaic Influences;
All we know for sure is this life and the history of other lives. Life after death is purely speculative and Jews do not believe that this life is a preparation for the afterlife. Yet in spite of that, there is an almost unspoken assumption amongst Jews that they will be rewarded for a virtuous life, after death. For example, the prayer in the house of mourning: "Have mercy upon him. Pardon all him transgressions for there is none righteous upon the earth who doeth only good and sinneth not. Remember unto him the righteousness that he wrought and let his reward be with him and his recompense before him - bestow upon him the abounding happiness that is treasured up for the righteous". And yet paradoxically, on leaving the house of mourning our greeting to the principle mourners is to wish them a long life. We believe that life is of infinite worth and as infinity cannot be split then every moment of a life is of infinite value. We are therefore commanded to strive to preserve and prolong life and to avoid hazardous activities that risk our lives (and that should include smoking). This also explains our contempt for the suicide bombers, those who send them on their way and those who worship them as martyrs.
There are of course, some mystical Chasidic sects who wish to explore the meaning of life and speculate on the afterlife, but mainstream Judaism accepts life as an end in itself and our religious teachings are primarily aimed at providing a code of conduct with more attention being paid to the relationships between man and man than between man and his God. Even to question whether life has a meaning may be a meaningless question to a Jew. If life is an end in itself then to question its meaning is as empty an exercise as to question the meaning of virtue, truth and beauty. If there is a meaning to life then it has to be beyond our comprehension however many subtle clues may pass across our consciousness. We are analogous to the fish trying to comprehend life on earth when all its fish-like brain can perceive are distorted two-dimensional images that appear in its firmament. I would even go further and suggest it is the ultimate in intellectual arrogance to "know" the answer to this question. I happen to note that there is a tendency amongst those who “know” with certainty, to impose their beliefs on others and this in my opinion is the source of most of the world's problems. This confident knowledge of the unknowable leads to religious fundamentalism, forced conversion, terrorism and the three horsemen of the apocalypse.

The Teachings of Biological Science
It is natural for human beings to see patterns in their life. For every effect they like to know the cause. For example, is cancer a punishment? Is it a fault of lifestyle? Is it in the family? Why me? For every patient therefore, there is an emotional need to understand a little about the nature of cancer if only to remove the guilt and the stigma, which has been associated with it in the past. The aetiology of cancer probably involves two basic steps: initiation, which may be a necessary but not sufficient cause, and a second set of events, which are described as promotional. Apart from the rare cases of genetic predisposition to cancer, initiating factors are exogenous (from without) whereas promotional factors are largely constitutional (from within). There are some obvious examples where clearly defined exogenous factors initiate the disease and where in theory prevention is possible. The best example of course is smoking and its impact on the incidence of lung cancer, bladder cancer and head and neck cancer. Another well established example of this kind is the association between malignant melanoma of the skin and the exposure of white races to excessive sunlight. It is likely that the initiation of the majority of common and for that matter, uncommon cancers are random events resulting from exogenous factors beyond our control leading to somatic mutations in the human genome. These may result from cosmic rays, radon from the granite of the earth or the low, persistent background of x-radiation. We assume that there are constant random mutations occurring within our genome, but we have exquisite repair mechanisms and to an extent our vulnerability to cancer may not be so much due to the exogenous factors as to inherent failures of our natural repair mechanisms. We are thus rapidly developing a mechanistic concept of the nature of cancer, which will ultimately lead to rational biological cures. In the meantime, we have to ask whether this increasing knowledge can help us understand cancer from the humanistic point of view. How can a cancer doctor retain any semblance of faith, which is tested each time he witnesses the suffering imposed by this dreadful disease. Paradoxically, each time I contemplate the micro-cosmos of the cancer cell, I find my faith restored. Of course it is commonplace to see God’s work in the cosmos as illustrated by the last paragraph of Stephen Hawking's best seller "A Brief History of Time": "There may be only one complete unified theory that is self-consistent and allow the existence of structures as complicated as human beings who can investigate the laws of the universe and ask about the nature of God. If we find the answer to that, it would be the ultimate triumph of human reason, for then we would know the mind of God". I enjoy the same sense of awe from the study of inner space rather than outer space. Watson and Crick discovered the structure of DNA in 1953 and subsequent biological scientists have come up with mind-boggling statistics as awe inspiring as those related to cosmology. Richard Dawkins puts it this way. There are 3 x 1012 cells in the body and 46 chromosomes per cell. 2 meters of DNA are packed into the nucleus of each cell tightly wound on these chromosomes. That is 6 x 1012 meters of DNA in each body, which is equivalent to the distance to the moon and back 8000 times! Each time the cell divides there is the hazard of a somatic mutation as a random event. Some cells divide every 48 hours. It is therefore a miracle to me that life can be sustained at all and the question "why me?" whenever someone develops cancer should be turned on its head and every day of everyone's life we should offer up a prayer that we didn't develop cancer in the previous 24 hours. Richard Dawkins in his most readable and mischievous book "The Blind Watchmaker" describes the fidelity of the transcription process beautifully and I wish to quote one of his passages at length: "DNA's performance as an archival medium is spectacular. In its capacity to preserve a message it far outdoes tablets of stone. Letters carved on gravestones become unreadable in mere hundreds of years. The DNA document is even more impressive, because unlike tablets of stone it is not the same physical structure that lasts and preserves the text. It is repeatedly being copied and recopied as the generations go by, like the Hebrew Scriptures, which were ritually copied by scribes every eighty years to forestall their wearing out. It is hard to estimate how many times the DNA document has been recopied in our lineage; probably as many as twenty billion times. It is hard to find a yardstick with which to compare the preservation of more than 99% of the information in twenty billion successive copying."
Such precision is miraculous. Life in the first place is miraculous and preservation of our species is miraculous. Cancer is the inevitable result of any instability within the human genome without which evolution would have been postponed. Cancer therefore is the inevitable result of the gift of life and the evolution of a species to its current state of self-awareness that allows it to ask such questions. We should therefore give thanks for this gift however brief the candle within our grasp. It is of course a mute point as to whom or what we give thanks. That is another question mischievously addressed by Richard Dawkins, in his book the God Delusion. That aside one could therefore say that in asking the question "What is the meaning of life?" we are effectively looking a gift horse in the mouth. It could then be argued why have I been wasting my time as a clinical scientist?
I have given you the biologist's reason to believe, which includes a belief in reason but I also believe in something transcendental (pace Dawkins) which encourages me challenge nature.

Lessons from the Study of Fine Art
If life is a miracle, a gift and an end in itself, how do we judge a good life and for how long should we try to extend that life. It is to address these fundamental questions that I have to turn to the arts for guidance. Great works of art, whether they are paintings, music or literature are judged by their capacity to illustrate, interpret and enhance life's experience. I would like to take this definition and use fine art itself as the metaphor to set the parameters for a good and appropriately lengthy life. When judging a great painting I look for harmony of composition, balance of colour and tone and its capacity to evoke emotions of joy or understanding, but even someone unschooled in the appreciation of fine art can recognize an unfinished work when he sees it. For example, Leonardo da Vinci's Adoration of the Kings in the Uffizi Gallery, Florence: this has perfect composition and perspective and certain areas are beautifully sketched in, namely the heads of the Magi and some rearing horses in the distance, yet it is clearly unfinished. Apart from areas of ground colour there is little else to give it depth or please the eye with harmony of hue. One despairs of so many of Leonardo's works that remain unfinished as tributes to his flawed genius.
I believe life should be worked upon as with any other expression of the human craving to produce perfection. A good life can be judged at any one time by its horizontal harmonies judged by relationships with family and friends, satisfaction with work or professional advancement and the capacity to enjoy leisure and recreation. Looking at life vertically a complete and balanced composition would include a time for childhood games, a time for education, a time for marriage and homebuilding, a time for the conception and raising of children, a time to hand over to the next generation, to retire and enjoy the fruits of one's labour and finally a time for a dignified death. Not all of us are capable of creating great works of art, but there is an art in the striving for achievement and even a tragically foreshortened life can leave beauty behind like an unfinished symphony.
My brother David
Let me remind you about my young brother David. He had a lean and hungry look crowned by a huge head of curly hair that made one think of Harpo Marx. He wore exuberant bow ties, did magic and was a deeply religious Jew, indeed a “Shomer Shabbat”. (literally meaning Guardian of the Sabbath). In contrast I am portly and balding, I wear normal ties and respect those laws of the Sabbath that suit me. We came from the same genetic pool but were of different phenotypes and yet in parts our brains seemed to have been hard- wired in a similar way. He was also a clinical scientist but a pediatrician. He was a fanatically hard worker and set the pace when we used to study together as undergraduates young post grads in Birmingham.
On his death he left behind him his wife Angela, an artist and four wonderful boys, Benjamin (Buzz), Joshua, Jacob and Samuel. It was only at his memorial service in Bristol attended by thousands, did I learn of all his achievements in promoting children’s health around the globe and the promotion of the hospice movement for children dying of cancer. He combined a zeal for life fueled by his faith and his candle burnt out prematurely flaming at both ends. But what a life, a masterpiece of a life, a life full of colour and perfect symmetry yet in many ways an unfinished symphony of a life. He never lived to enjoy that golden retirement he dreamed of, with him studying Talmud in Sefad with Angela painting by his side. The nearest he came to that was his burial plot in Rosh Pinah overlooking his beloved Kineret (The Sea of Galilee). Yet in his for-shortened life he achieved more than most could achieve if they lived to be 120.
The Rajastani Potter
In October 1994, my wife and I visited India to take in the UICC World Cancer Congress in New Delhi. We took advantage of this visit to enjoy a very comfortable and spectacular tour of the Golden Triangle in Rajasthan. On this visit I learnt that of the population of India, which numbers approximately one billion, seven hundred and fifty million live in abject poverty with a life expectancy thirty years less than our own. One cannot possibly begin to imagine the enormity of such numbers and once again it is necessary in order to gain the slightest of insights, to focus in on the life of a single individual. We enjoyed three magnificent days staying in the lap of luxury in the Lake Palace Hotel in Udaipur. On one of these days our guide took us through the hills and jungle north of Udaipur to visit the Jain Temples of Ranakpur. Along the way he made a diversion so that we could visit a small rural village where he was well known. Stopping at the side of a rutted and primitive road we continued our journey on foot through all kinds of excreta and rubbish past stagnant pools where the colourful women of Rajasthan were beating their saris clean; through a tumbledown village of mud-bricks and collapsing thatch to a little shed to watch the potter at his work. As always, I enjoyed the creation of an artifact out of formless clay. The potter enjoyed our interest and his wife and countless children were thrilled by the visit of alien creatures from what might have been another planet. Their interest and amusement with us, and the offers of hospitality were disarmingly genuine. This seemed to be a man, happy with the weft of his life strengthened by his family network and the beauty and utility of the objects he was creating. Also, from what I learned during my visit to India, the warp of his life was punctuated by Hindu festivals and rituals. Like many of the poor and uneducated in India, he was blissfully unaware of the alternative lifestyle enjoyed by us Westerners and so probably lacked the ambition to "improve himself" and had no desire for consumer durables or skiing holidays. I am well aware that it is easy to romanticize this squalor and look upon this harmless man as a “noble savage”, but just as we should try and improve on nature with finding a cure for cancer I believe it should be an expression of our humanity to improve upon nurture so that the health and welfare of this family could be improved. I cannot believe that his life would lose much of value if all his children had a good education and were able to realize their full potential and enjoy the artistic traditions of their own society. I don't believe anything of value would be lost by trying to reduce the appalling infant mortality by the simple expedient of providing fresh, uncontaminated running water and I cannot believe that much of value would be lost if the potter lived long enough to enjoy his grandchildren. This then leaves me with a troubling thought. Would India, or for that matter, the rest of the world, be a better place if there were fewer citizens with more complete lives. In other words is birth control and easy access to abortion the only answers to these questions. I certainly don't side with the pro- life fanatics in the United States of America. I can think of no greater obscenity than those who commit murder in the name of the unborn. I tend to side with the sardonic political commentator P J O'Rourke. In his book “All the Worlds Troubles” he points out with devastating logic that population density per se is not the cause of poverty and misery and emphasizes that certain areas of Southern California have a greater population density than the Delta area of Bangladesh. His explanation for the cause of poverty, misery and a high infant mortality is the direct correlation of these world troubles with nations that practice religious intolerance, feudalism and corruption.
Returning now to my metaphor of the weft and warp of life; I recognize that to describe life as a rich tapestry is a rather exhausted cliché, but it will serve my purpose now. A character in Somerset Maughan's lovely fable "A Moon and Sixpence", someone who is clearly a prototype hippy, carries with him at all times a rolled up Persian carpet. He uses this as a “memento vitae”. It had always been my ambition to emulate this character and one of the other great successes of our visit to India was to bring back a silken Kashmiri carpet. Due to some brilliant bargaining on behalf of my wife we were able to purchase this exquisite work of art at barely twice what it cost the vendor! Like all true Kashmiri silk carpets it is indeed magic. Viewed from my current position at my writing desk I can enjoy its robust and intricate patterns suggestive of the mathematics of a complex organism. The colours are vivid, rich and dark. Viewed from the other side, it takes on an entirely different character. The shades are pastel, the outlines of the design ephemeral and the carpet appears to float above the ground. Give me my current perspective of this carpet any day and let the metaphysicians enjoy the alternative viewpoint as much as they like, providing they don't impose their view of life on me by forced conversion, torture or decree.

Returning to the Case in Point
Let me now return to the case of the young woman twenty one weeks' pregnant with impending spinal cord compression from metastatic breast cancer. As an informed and carefully calculated choice she allowed the pregnancy to go to thirty two weeks before delivery through Caesarean section. This compromise allowed a new life into the world with an almost 100% chance of survival in health to adult life. This child is a reminder to her husband of his late wife. This child allows a beautiful symmetry in her for-shortened life denied on the previous occasion at the time of her initial diagnosis. I supported her in this decision from my own ethical standpoint because I was not actively shortening her life for the benefit of the child. This new life started at a disadvantage because of the limited life expectancy of the mother, but the starting point for all works of art are of an infinite variety and what could be a less promising subject than say Van Gough's shoes? Although as a Jew I will always value the life of a mother over the potential life of a foetus, I can recognize the persuasiveness of the argument that a potential life may be valued equally with the fully developed life of the adult.
------
20 years ago I suffered a severe bout of clinical depression. Only fellow sufferers will fully appreciate what this mean. That mood is certainly well illustrated in the passage from Macbeth quoted at the start of this chapter. No amount of reassurance from my family or friends could persuade me that I was of any worth and that my life had any meaning. Towards the end of this illness I experienced an episode that can only be described as a sunburst of happiness and in a crude attempt to emulate Van-Gough I described this feeling with a painting of sunflowers created with a palate knife and thick impasto. Although frightful at that time I think that period of illness was of enormous and lasting value to me. Many people live their life taking it for granted without truly valuing the gift. There is no better way of describing my attitude to life than by using the words of George Bernard Shaw whose feelings are the complete antithesis to those Shakespeare expressed through the mouth of Macbeth:
"This is the true joy in life, the being used for a purpose recognized by yourself as a mighty one, the being a force of nature instead of a feverish little clod of ailments and grievances complaining that the world will not devote itself to making you happy. I am of the opinion that my life belongs to the whole community, and as long as I live it is my privilege to do for it whatever I can. I want to be thoroughly used up when I die, for the harder I work the more I live. I rejoice in life for its own sake. Life is no brief candle to me. It is a sort of splendid torch which I have got hold of for the moment and I want to make it burn as brightly as possible before handing it on to future generations."
That was how my brother David lived his life and thus was the manner of his parting.




















No comments: