The illusions and delusions of screening for cancer.
“The largest threat posed by American medicine is that more and more of us are being drawn into the system not because of an epidemic of disease, but because of an epidemic of diagnoses. The real problem with the epidemic of diagnoses is that it leads to an epidemic of treatments. Not all treatments have important benefits, but almost all can have harms” 1
Introduction
A couple of weeks ago I was showing off my newly acquired iPhone to my very bright 12-year-old granddaughter when she elected to “Google” my name. To my amazement the top hit appeared to link my name with that of Jade Goody. As far as I could recall I had never met with her, I have never knowingly watched Big Brother and I don’t even research or treat cervical cancer. It appears that I was being stigmatized as the leading anti-screening dinosaur. Everything became clear when on Monday the 23rd March 2009, the Times published a full- page obituary on the short and tragic life of the reality TV celebrity, Jade Goody, whose dying wish was that women under the age of 25 should have access to screening for cervical cancer. The “Goody effect” has already provoked a campaign and a response from the department of health. I have nothing against the late Jade, in fact she reminded me of the type of patient that used to make my NHS clinics in central London such fun.
Nevertheless I feel the urge to defend myself and to explain why being a screening sceptic might after all place on the side of the angels rather than to the darker side of Darth Vader. For a start I must hasten to mention that some of my best friends are women. My beloved mother died of breast cancer and my equally beloved sister is a long- term survivor of the disease. Galvanized by this experience I’ve devoted my whole professional life to fighting breast cancer, visualizing it as a slavering beast and in moments of self-delusion seeing myself as St. Michael. My wife’s reminder, that this brand name is sewn in the back of my underpants, tends to bring me down to earth.
In addition I actually know a thing or two about screening. In 1987 when I was employed as Professor of Surgery at Kings College Hospital, I was commissioned by the DoH to establish the first breast-screening unit following the publication of the Forrest report. This unit was built near Camberwell Green in South East London and served as the training centre for the South-East of England. Furthermore for the last 8 years I’ve acted as the chairman of the National trial to evaluate PSA screening for the early detection of prostate cancer.
Suddenly a confluence of events has thrown the subject of screening for cancer into the public eye again. To start with there was the publication of the Nordic Cochrane centre on mammographic screening in the BMJ in February 20092 along with an open letter to the Times signed by me amongst 27 other experts, both of which provoked a debate on the wisdom of screening for breast cancer. Then there were two papers published in the New England Journal of Medicine in March, reporting on the early results of screening for prostate cancer by using the PSA blood test.3,4 This was accompanied by banner headlines in the Daily Telegraph demanding PSA screening on the NHS that could save 2,000 lives a year. Later on I will explain just how wrong this statement was but before then it behoves me to explain some of the delusions and illusions of screening in general.
“For every complex problem there is a simple solution-and it’s wrong”5
The majority of lay people could be forgiven for believing that one of the mainstays in the fight against cancer is “early detection”. This belief has generated a European wide consensus that screening for cancer before it becomes symptomatic will save lives. It has also become the main plank in the government’s campaign to improve cancer survival in the UK to match the highest levels achieved in the EU. In the vanguard of this campaign, the NHS screening programme for breast cancer (NHSBSP) by mammography has been lauded as a triumph and has laid claim to the responsibility for the dramatic decline in breast cancer mortality since its initiation more than 20 years ago. Those of us who have remained sceptical from the start have been branded as either misogynists or fools. Furthermore if its good enough for women, what about men’s health as well? How can early detection of cancer be a bad thing? Although counterintuitive, a growing body of informed opinion is moving in that direction.
Biases of screening that can disguise the truth and the diagnosis of “pseudo-cancers”.
Let us start by considering two separate but related issues; firstly biases of screening that give a false impression of benefit and secondly the over-detection of cancer “look-alikes” that if left undetected might never threaten a patient’s life. The survival from cancer is measured from the time of detection until recurrence and death. If a frame shift in the chronology of the disease due to screening occurs, then survival is automatically extended even if the ultimate outcome is the same; this is called lead-time bias. Of course if the “cancer” detected would never have threatened a woman’s life in the first instance then that lead time might be as long as 30 years. Next, bearing in mind that the interval between screens is anything from one to three years, it is inevitable that the fast growing tumours with a bad prognosis will appear during the intervals whilst the slow growing tumours with a good prognosis will sit around until found by mammography; this is called length bias. There is also another subtle bias that can be described as the “self selection” bias. In that women who accept invitations for screening might be demographically different to those who ignore the invitation. For a variety of reasons such women have better outcomes in the treatment of cancer forgetting whether they were screen detected or not. The only way to account for these biases is to consider all the clinical trials of screening versus no screening and look for the pooled results described in terms of mortality i.e. the number of women dying in the screened group compared with those dying in the control group rather than case survival. There is in fact a modest advantage to screening looked upon in those terms, as described in the recent publication in the BMJ; “Breast screening: the facts—or maybe not” by Peter C Gøtzsche and his colleagues from the influential and independent, Nordic Cochrane Centre.2
In this milestone paper they describe a synthesis of all the papers that describe both the benefits and harms of screening using absolute rather than relative numbers that make easy for women comprehend and conclude as follows. If 2000 women are screened regularly for 10 years, one will benefit from the screening, as she will avoid dying from breast cancer. (The U.S.Preventive Services Task Force derived a similar number independently in 2004.6 ) However even the 1:2,000 might be an over-estimate. Remember these data were derived from the trials that were mostly started in the 1970s and reported in the late 1980s. Since then improvements in treatment, such as the adoption of tamoxifen and adjuvant chemotherapy, have narrowed the window of opportunity and we have witnessed a drop in mortality of 30%- 40% both in the age group that are invited for screening (>50) as well as for the younger woman. So perhaps the correct number might be 1:2,000 X 0.6, i.e.1:3,000
Forgetting the precise number, that one woman who benefits from a decade of screening has a life of infinite worth and if screening were as non-toxic as wearing a seat belt there would be no case to answer. However there is a downside and that is the problem of the over-diagnosis of “pseudo-cancers”. It is deduced by the Cochrane report that for every life saved10 healthy women will, as a consequence, become cancer patients and will be treated unnecessarily. These women will have either a part of their breast or the whole breast removed, and they will often receive radiotherapy and sometimes chemotherapy. This is the tricky part of the story that is more or less denied by the screening fraternity and therefore deserves some close attention.
An explanation for, and the nature of, the over-diagnosed cancers
Screening for breast cancer is now adopted as an unequivocal good by most of the members of the EU. Invitations for screening promote this activity by being economical with the truth.7 One of the uncomfortable truths concerns the over-diagnosis of both in-situ and invasive breast cancers in screening populations.8 Over-diagnosis of breast cancer doesn’t mean false positive rates but the detection and treatment of cancers that left undetected would never threaten a woman’s life and with which she would live, in blissful unawareness until she died naturally of old age. We had always assumed that there was an over-diagnosis of duct carcinoma in-situ (DCIS), some of which had the potential of progressing to an invasive and life-threatening phenotype. However, there is now clear evidence that anything between 10% and 50% of invasive cancers detected and treated radically as a result of screening, would never threaten life.9 As a result the overall mastectomy rate rises after any country implements screening in contrast to the message in the NHSBSP leaflet, “breast cancer the facts” 10 that implies that screening saves breasts. It doesn't.
How can this possibly be? Don’t we know that if cancer is neglected it will progress to a life threatening condition?
By way of illumination let me propose that the pathological diagnosis of cancer at screening is based on a syllogism; (a syllogism is a logical argument in three propositions, two premises and a conclusion, the conclusion being specious) A simple example might be that people who die from meningitis, harbour meningococci in their nose. This does not mean that harbouring meningococci in the nose is a lethal condition, in fact about 10% of the population harbour these bacteria. Cancer was defined by its microscopic appearance about two hundred years ago. The 19th century saw the birth of scientific oncology with the discovery and use of the modern microscope. Rudolf Virchow, often called the founder of cellular pathology, provided the scientific basis for the modern pathologic study of cancer. As earlier generations had correlated the autopsy findings observed with the unaided eye with the clinical course of cancer one hundred years earlier, so Virchow correlated the microscopic pathology of the disease.
However the material he was studying came from the autopsy of patients dying from cancer. In the mid 19thC pathological correlations were performed on living subjects presenting with locally advanced or metastatic disease that almost always were pre-determined to die in the absence of effective therapy. Since then without pause for thought, the microscopic identification of cancer according to these classic criteria has been associated with the assumed prognosis of a fatal disease if left untreated. The syllogism at the heart of the diagnosis of cancer therefore runs like this; people frequently die from malignant disease, under the microscope this malignant disease has many histological features we will call “cancer”, ergo anything that looks like “cancer” under the microscope, will kill you. I would therefore like to argue that some of these earliest stages of “cancer” if left unperturbed, would not progress to a disease with lethal potential. These “pseudo-cancers” might have microscopic similarity to true cancers but these appearances are only a necessary rather than sufficient condition for a fatal disease. I would also like to suggest that many of the “risk factors” for the development of cancer are in fact the promotional agents of a latent condition that Welch has described as pseudo-cancers1. If we stand back at take a broader look at nature this shouldn’t be surprising. Conventional mathematical models of cancer growth are linear or logarithmic, in other words completely predictable at the outset. These mathematical formulae may be appropriate for designing theme park rides but cannot begin to explain the exquisite organization of cell proliferation and the complex inter-relationships of cells of different progeny.
Most natural biological mechanisms are non-linear or better described according to chaos theory. The beauty of the tree in full leaf is reflects its fractal geometry that looks remarkably similar to the microscopic appearance of the mammary ducts and lobules under the microscope. The rate of growth and the development of the lung along with the fingers and toes in the foetus, cannot be described in linear terms. Wound healing starts with the knife and ends when it needs to, although rarely wound healing carries on too long to leave an ugly keloid scar. Prolonged latency followed by catastrophe should not be all that surprising. We accept the case for prostate cancer, as we know that most elderly men will die with prostate cancer in situ and not of prostate cancer that has invaded. In fact the UK national PSA screening trial is predicated on that fact with two a priori outcome measures defined, deaths from prostate cancer versus the number of cancers treated unnecessarily. Why oh why does the breast cancer lobby remain in denial? Of course now that the cat is out the bag they will have no choice but to include this fact in their invitations in order to avoid litigation from an irate woman in the future. Furthermore “the sins of the mother are visited on the daughter”. We now have cases of women with screen detected DCIS whose daughters have had problems raising mortgages when the insurers have discovered this family history of breast cancer! 11,12 However even the concession by the DoH on this fact, as reported in the Times, only acknowledges one cancer over-diagnosed for every life saved. How on earth do they derive that number? The Cochrane report is transparent on this matter and the numbers are there for all to see. They simply record the numbers of breast cancers that have appeared in the screened group (observed) and subtracted the numbers expected as seen in the unscreened control populations in the trials that have now been followed up for the majority of these women’s lifetimes.
(Observed-expected = over-diagnosis) How the DoH arrived at the figure of one to one is therefore inexplicable. The charitable conclusion is that they were caught off guard and trotted out the figures that are 10 years out of date rather than being guilty of a “dodgy dossier”.
Prostate cancer
By way of a minor diversion I want briefly to mention prostate cancer screening. In my preamble I mentioned the banner headlines in one of our respected broadsheets following the publications in the New England Journal of Medicine in March 2009.3,4 Well unlike the writers of that piece I actually read the publications and not just the press release of a prostate cancer charity. There were in fact two studies reported together with a lengthy editorial. The first study was American and produced a negative result. The larger European study was of borderline statistical significance and for the statistically literate amongst you, showed a 20% relative risk reduction of cancer specific mortality over a 10 year period with a p value of <0.04. Never mind the stats, translated into numbers that all lay men could understand, you would need to screen 1,400 men for 10 years to save one prostate cancer death at the expense of over-diagnosing 48 cases of cancer that would be treated with radical surgery that frequently lead to impotence and incontinence and on rare occasions death from the complications of surgery. The editorial concluded that it was premature to make any kind of recommendation and urged that we waited for the outcome of the British trial. That happens to be the study I chair. I can claim no credit for the elegant and ambitious design of that trial that is all down to the three principle investigators, Freddie Hamdy, Jenny Donovan and David Neal. I was invited in as an independent chairman to see fair play. 500,000 men in the UK have been randomized to PSA screening or not. Those with a raised PSA are further investigated and if in the end their prostate biopsies showed localized cancer they are then offered re-randomization to three treatment groups, radical surgery, radical radiotherapy or “active monitoring”. The two primary outcome measures are cancer specific mortality and the rate of over-diagnosis. Health economics is factored in as well and the secondary randomization will allow measures of quality of life as well as length of life in the different treatment groups, whilst the “active monitoring” arm will allow us to study the natural history of screen detected prostate cancer. This latter group will also allow us to study the molecular biology of the disease to see if we can learn to separate out the “poodles” (cancers that will remain latent for the duration of life) from the “Rottweiler’s” (those that are predetermined to invade and spread). If only we had our time over again that is how the breast cancer trials should have been designed!
Is there a reasonable “exit strategy”?
Let me summarize in a series of bullet points where we have arrived with breast cancer screening.
• The current NHS screening programme is based on the results of randomized controlled trials that were published before 1987 and started in the late 1960s and early 1970s
• Some of these trials in retrospect were of poor quality
• With mature follow up, careful attention to biases a relative risk reduction (RRR) in breast cancer specific mortality has been estimated as 15%
• In absolute terms therefore the numbers needed to screen over 10 years to prevent one breast cancer death is about 1:2,000. Anything better than this depends on ignoring the obvious biases in the trials, mathematical manipulation of the data that I either simply don’t understand or is based on those self -selected women who accept the invitation to screen. (“Selection bias”)
• Along the way the estimates of harm have increased. At the outset the hazards of over-diagnosis were ignored, then as the rate of screen detected duct carcinoma in situ (DCIS) shot up it was still judged to be worth the cost. Now we recognize that the over-diagnosis of invasive cancers (IDC) that are not predestined to threaten a woman’s life is a problem. The extent of over-diagnosis is debateable but I personally agree that if you include DCIS and IDC it mounts to about 10 cases treated unnecessarily for every life saved.
• Putting politics aside for the moment I wonder how many of us would have voted for the NHSBSP in 1987 knowing what we know today.
• Furthermore in spite of the wonderful advances we’ve made in imaging technology and treatment in the last 20 years there has been only one new trial reported for screening and that was the trial for the under 50s that supported the 15% estimate.13
• In other words we are using state of the art imaging and modern therapy to service a programme based on data that is 20 years old. It is also worth re-iterating at this juncture that improvements in the treatment of symptomatic patients since the mid 1980s leaves a much narrower window of opportunity for screening so that even our estimates of 1: 2,000 based on these old trials might have to be multiplied by a factor of about 0.6.
• So where do we go from here? To close the programme is politically unacceptable. I therefore want to make two practical propositions for research and development. One concerns “person preferences” and the other concerns the more efficient use of scarce resources that I will refer to as risk assessment/risk management (RARM)
Person preference
Since 1997 when I resigned from the NHSBS committee I have publically expressed my concerns on the issue of informed choice for women invited for screening. This has often led to ridicule and ad hominum attacks. I take no particular pleasure in the fact that NHS has at last accepted the point and agreed to rewrite the letters of invitation.
From The Times February 21, 2009
“NHS rips up breast cancer leaflet and starts all over again”
My concern is that they will repeat the mistakes of the past if we leave this task to the usual suspects. Furthermore it’s not for me to prejudge what level of benefit and what level of harm might influence the average woman to accept the invitation. For this reason I think there are two related areas of research. First the development of an information pack that includes decision aids. This could be used in a person preference study where well women might be offered sliding scales of benefits and harms to find the point at which screening is judged acceptable. These data might then inform the next and perhaps more important area of research on more efficient ways of using scarce resources in the NHS.
RARM
The beauty of a risk assessment risk management is that it provides a platform for the management of all women in an attempt to reduce the mortality from breast cancer where mammographic screening is one component of an integrated programme. The first step is to set up a facility nation wide for risk assessment using one of the modern computer programmes. Women would then be offered not compelled to accept this service. Initially a practice nurse could administer this questionnaire but it would be quite easy to transfer this to a web- based programme for the computer literate members of the community. From the read-out an initial triage could be agreed. Those at the most extreme end of the risk spectrum, say with a relative risk (RR) of say >10.0, could be invited to a clinical genetics consultation. At the other extreme those with a RR of say <2.0 might be reassured and given lifestyle advise on diet, alcohol and exercise. (Please note that these risk ratios are for illustration only, the actual figures used could be derived from the person preference studies and the cut off for genetic counselling is already broadly accepted) Those in between could then be invited to a special clinic for the second step. At this clinic women of 45 or older could have a mammogram to determine breast density that might also be kept as a baseline but also provide additional evidence about risk. (The greater the mammographic density the higher the risk) Those with radiological abnormality at this stage would be investigated in the accepted way. If the mammographic density is low and the repeat estimate falls below a RR of 2.0 then they would be reassured and given lifestyle advise. Those that remain with a RR 2.0-10.0 would be offered screening. In addition those who were pre-menopausal might be offered prevention with tamoxifen and those who were post-menopausal could be offered entry into the IBIS II trial, a study comparing tamoxifen with arimidex for the chemo-prophylaxis of breast cancer). A recent paper in JNCI supports the validity of this approach.14
Conclusion
To carry on regardless is no longer acceptable neither is political spin the answer. Women are now getting smarter and the demand for change doesn’t just come from grumpy old men like me but also from the legions of wise women represented by the signatories of the letter in the Times. However the changes I have in mind are not destructive but constructive. The NHSBSP has indirectly lead to the provision of the best specialist services for the diagnosis and treatment of symptomatic breast cancer in the world, riding on the back of the screening units. The centralization of care has lead to the rapid recruitment into RCTs for the treatment of cancer that is the major contributor to the dramatic fall in breast cancer mortality in the UK over the last two decades. If we can now add to this the prevention of the disease and a risk adjusted screening programme then everyone is a winner.
References
[1] What’s Making Us Sick Is an Epidemic of Diagnoses
H. GILBERT WELCH, LISA SCHWARTZ and STEVEN WOLOSHIN
The New York Times, January 2, 2007
[2] “Breast screening: the facts—or maybe not”, Gøtzsche PC et al
BMJ 2009, 338; 446-448
[3] Mortality results from a randomized prostate screening trial. Andriole et al. NEJM 2009, 360: 1310-1319
[4] Screening and prostate cancer mortality in a randomized European trial.
Schroder et al NEJM 2009, 360:1320-1328
[5] Aphorism of American humorist H.L. Menken
[6] U.S.Preventive Services Task Force. Screening for Breast Cancer: Recommendations and Rationale. Ann Intern Med 2002;137: 344-6.
[7] Screening and choice: Informed choice for screening: implications for evaluation. Les Irwig, Kirsten McCaffery, Glenn Salkeld, Patrick Bossuyt: BMJ 2006;332:1148-1150,
[8] Rate of over-diagnosis of breast cancer 15 years after end of Malmö mammographic screening trial: follow up study. Zackrisson S, Andersson I, Manjer J and Garne JP, BMJ 2006;332:689-92
[9] “Should I be tested for Cancer?” H.Gilbert Welch
University of California Press, 2004, ISBN 0520239768
[10] Incidence of breast cancer in Norway and Sweden during introduction of nationwide screening: prospective cohort study. Zahl PH, Strand BH, Maehlen J. BMJ. 2004 Apr 17;328(7445):921-4.
[11] “Randomised Clinical Trials: the patient`s point of view.” Hazel Thornton,
in Ductal Carcinoma in Situ of the Breast. Ed. Melvin Silverstein. Williams and Wilkins 1997.
[12] Insurance repercussions of mammographic screening: What do women think? Claire Davey, Victoria White, Jenette E. Ward. Medical Science Monitor 2003; 8:LE44-45
[13] Effect of mammographic screening from age 40 years on breast cancer mortality at 10 years’ follow up: a randomised controlled trial. Moss SM, Cuckle H, Evans A, Johns L, Waller M, Bobrow L, The Lancet 2006, 368; 2053-2060
[14] Prevention of Breast Cancer in Postmenopausal Women: Approaches to Estimating and Reducing Risk: Steven R. Cummings, Jeffrey A. Tice, Scott Bauer, Warren S. Browne, Jack Cuzick et al; J Natl Cancer Inst 2009;101:
384 – 398
Wednesday, 1 April 2009
Sunday, 1 July 2007
PREFACE

The meaning of life and other easy questions!
"Tomorrow and tomorrow and tomorrow creeps in this petty pace from day to day to the last syllable of recorded time and all our yesterdays have lighted fools the way to dusty death. Out, out brief candle! Life's but a walking shadow. A poor player that struts and frets his hour upon the stage until he is heard no more. It is a tale told by an idiot full of sound and fury signifying nothing."
Macbeth Act V Scene V.
I learnt this soliloquy from Macbeth by heart, at about the age of seven and used it as my "party piece" whenever my parents had the opportunity to show off their gifted children in front of an appreciative audience of family and friends. What my parents could never have predicted was the consequence of my sudden understanding of this bleak passage, when at about the age of eleven, I embarked on my lifelong career an insomniac. I remember clearly as a precocious young boy, lying awake all night trying to determine which was worse, to live forever, or to die at some uncertain point in the future and what was life all about anyway? Shakespeare's suggestion that it signified nothing added a new layer or terror to my troubled nights. However, with the passage of time my experience of life (and for that matter my experience of death), I think I've been able to define the questions with considerable more maturity than that of the pre-pubescent lad. I therefore welcomed the opportunity this memoir provides me with, to try to synthesize fifty years of self-questioning as to the meaning of life and the relevance of this to my clinical practice.
My attitude to the big question has been shaped by three major influences. These influences have been my upbringing as a Jew, my scientific curiosity as a practicing clinical scientist and my lifelong passionate affair with the visual arts. I don't think it’s any exaggeration or particular conceit to say that sometimes I have to draw on all these inner resources in counseling my patients to help them make difficult decisions that might influence both the length and quality of their lives.
In the quiet doldrums between Christmas and the end of the New Year holiday break in 1995, I was called in to help a young woman make one of the toughest choices that anyone can ever be called upon to decide.
In fact the decision reminded me of “Sophie’s choice” in William Styron’s tragic novel of the same name.
The young woman in question was a pretty Greek Orthodox girl aged thirty-one. Four years earlier she had been diagnosed with breast cancer at a time when she was twelve weeks pregnant. The pregnancy was terminated and she underwent a conventional course of treatment that involved surgery, radiotherapy and chemotherapy. She was very keen to start a family and I advised her to wait a year or two. It should be noted in passing that a pregnancy after breast cancer has been treated does not influence the prognosis, contrary to popular myth. At the time I was called in to advice, she was twenty -one weeks pregnant and had already felt the quickening of the baby in her womb. Tragically, she had also felt the symptoms of the secondary cancer in her spine. In addition to the severe pain that she experienced, she also described numbness and paresis affecting her left arm. Investigations demonstrated that there were metastases in the spine, compressing the spinal cord and the nerve roots to her left arm. The various therapeutic options we had to consider included surgery for immediate decompression of the spinal cord, radiotherapy to the vertebra and cytotoxic chemotherapy. To do nothing at that stage would have been unthinkable as without treatment she would have become paraplegic in about 48 hours. Yet, the most effective treatments to prevent this dreaded complication and to add to the length and quality to her remaining life, would compromise the health or viability of the baby in the womb. Whose life was of greater value and whose decision was it anyway? Was the potential life of the unborn more meaningful than prolonging the life of a young adult? I was hoping that her own religious beliefs would guide me in this tough decision, but when asked directly she confessed to being a lapsed Christian and asked me for all the facts so that she could make an informed choice. Amongst the difficult truths that I had to convey was the fact that with even the best of all treatments her expectation of life would be unlikely to exceed two years and therefore should she allow a new life into the world the baby would grow up motherless. There was clearly no correct answer to this dilemma and I will return to the conclusion of this sad story at the end of the chapter but first let me tell what influenced my advice.
Judaic Influences;
All we know for sure is this life and the history of other lives. Life after death is purely speculative and Jews do not believe that this life is a preparation for the afterlife. Yet in spite of that, there is an almost unspoken assumption amongst Jews that they will be rewarded for a virtuous life, after death. For example, the prayer in the house of mourning: "Have mercy upon him. Pardon all him transgressions for there is none righteous upon the earth who doeth only good and sinneth not. Remember unto him the righteousness that he wrought and let his reward be with him and his recompense before him - bestow upon him the abounding happiness that is treasured up for the righteous". And yet paradoxically, on leaving the house of mourning our greeting to the principle mourners is to wish them a long life. We believe that life is of infinite worth and as infinity cannot be split then every moment of a life is of infinite value. We are therefore commanded to strive to preserve and prolong life and to avoid hazardous activities that risk our lives (and that should include smoking). This also explains our contempt for the suicide bombers, those who send them on their way and those who worship them as martyrs.
There are of course, some mystical Chasidic sects who wish to explore the meaning of life and speculate on the afterlife, but mainstream Judaism accepts life as an end in itself and our religious teachings are primarily aimed at providing a code of conduct with more attention being paid to the relationships between man and man than between man and his God. Even to question whether life has a meaning may be a meaningless question to a Jew. If life is an end in itself then to question its meaning is as empty an exercise as to question the meaning of virtue, truth and beauty. If there is a meaning to life then it has to be beyond our comprehension however many subtle clues may pass across our consciousness. We are analogous to the fish trying to comprehend life on earth when all its fish-like brain can perceive are distorted two-dimensional images that appear in its firmament. I would even go further and suggest it is the ultimate in intellectual arrogance to "know" the answer to this question. I happen to note that there is a tendency amongst those who “know” with certainty, to impose their beliefs on others and this in my opinion is the source of most of the world's problems. This confident knowledge of the unknowable leads to religious fundamentalism, forced conversion, terrorism and the three horsemen of the apocalypse.
The Teachings of Biological Science
It is natural for human beings to see patterns in their life. For every effect they like to know the cause. For example, is cancer a punishment? Is it a fault of lifestyle? Is it in the family? Why me? For every patient therefore, there is an emotional need to understand a little about the nature of cancer if only to remove the guilt and the stigma, which has been associated with it in the past. The aetiology of cancer probably involves two basic steps: initiation, which may be a necessary but not sufficient cause, and a second set of events, which are described as promotional. Apart from the rare cases of genetic predisposition to cancer, initiating factors are exogenous (from without) whereas promotional factors are largely constitutional (from within). There are some obvious examples where clearly defined exogenous factors initiate the disease and where in theory prevention is possible. The best example of course is smoking and its impact on the incidence of lung cancer, bladder cancer and head and neck cancer. Another well established example of this kind is the association between malignant melanoma of the skin and the exposure of white races to excessive sunlight. It is likely that the initiation of the majority of common and for that matter, uncommon cancers are random events resulting from exogenous factors beyond our control leading to somatic mutations in the human genome. These may result from cosmic rays, radon from the granite of the earth or the low, persistent background of x-radiation. We assume that there are constant random mutations occurring within our genome, but we have exquisite repair mechanisms and to an extent our vulnerability to cancer may not be so much due to the exogenous factors as to inherent failures of our natural repair mechanisms. We are thus rapidly developing a mechanistic concept of the nature of cancer, which will ultimately lead to rational biological cures. In the meantime, we have to ask whether this increasing knowledge can help us understand cancer from the humanistic point of view. How can a cancer doctor retain any semblance of faith, which is tested each time he witnesses the suffering imposed by this dreadful disease. Paradoxically, each time I contemplate the micro-cosmos of the cancer cell, I find my faith restored. Of course it is commonplace to see God’s work in the cosmos as illustrated by the last paragraph of Stephen Hawking's best seller "A Brief History of Time": "There may be only one complete unified theory that is self-consistent and allow the existence of structures as complicated as human beings who can investigate the laws of the universe and ask about the nature of God. If we find the answer to that, it would be the ultimate triumph of human reason, for then we would know the mind of God". I enjoy the same sense of awe from the study of inner space rather than outer space. Watson and Crick discovered the structure of DNA in 1953 and subsequent biological scientists have come up with mind-boggling statistics as awe inspiring as those related to cosmology. Richard Dawkins puts it this way. There are 3 x 1012 cells in the body and 46 chromosomes per cell. 2 meters of DNA are packed into the nucleus of each cell tightly wound on these chromosomes. That is 6 x 1012 meters of DNA in each body, which is equivalent to the distance to the moon and back 8000 times! Each time the cell divides there is the hazard of a somatic mutation as a random event. Some cells divide every 48 hours. It is therefore a miracle to me that life can be sustained at all and the question "why me?" whenever someone develops cancer should be turned on its head and every day of everyone's life we should offer up a prayer that we didn't develop cancer in the previous 24 hours. Richard Dawkins in his most readable and mischievous book "The Blind Watchmaker" describes the fidelity of the transcription process beautifully and I wish to quote one of his passages at length: "DNA's performance as an archival medium is spectacular. In its capacity to preserve a message it far outdoes tablets of stone. Letters carved on gravestones become unreadable in mere hundreds of years. The DNA document is even more impressive, because unlike tablets of stone it is not the same physical structure that lasts and preserves the text. It is repeatedly being copied and recopied as the generations go by, like the Hebrew Scriptures, which were ritually copied by scribes every eighty years to forestall their wearing out. It is hard to estimate how many times the DNA document has been recopied in our lineage; probably as many as twenty billion times. It is hard to find a yardstick with which to compare the preservation of more than 99% of the information in twenty billion successive copying."
Such precision is miraculous. Life in the first place is miraculous and preservation of our species is miraculous. Cancer is the inevitable result of any instability within the human genome without which evolution would have been postponed. Cancer therefore is the inevitable result of the gift of life and the evolution of a species to its current state of self-awareness that allows it to ask such questions. We should therefore give thanks for this gift however brief the candle within our grasp. It is of course a mute point as to whom or what we give thanks. That is another question mischievously addressed by Richard Dawkins, in his book the God Delusion. That aside one could therefore say that in asking the question "What is the meaning of life?" we are effectively looking a gift horse in the mouth. It could then be argued why have I been wasting my time as a clinical scientist?
I have given you the biologist's reason to believe, which includes a belief in reason but I also believe in something transcendental (pace Dawkins) which encourages me challenge nature.
Lessons from the Study of Fine Art
If life is a miracle, a gift and an end in itself, how do we judge a good life and for how long should we try to extend that life. It is to address these fundamental questions that I have to turn to the arts for guidance. Great works of art, whether they are paintings, music or literature are judged by their capacity to illustrate, interpret and enhance life's experience. I would like to take this definition and use fine art itself as the metaphor to set the parameters for a good and appropriately lengthy life. When judging a great painting I look for harmony of composition, balance of colour and tone and its capacity to evoke emotions of joy or understanding, but even someone unschooled in the appreciation of fine art can recognize an unfinished work when he sees it. For example, Leonardo da Vinci's Adoration of the Kings in the Uffizi Gallery, Florence: this has perfect composition and perspective and certain areas are beautifully sketched in, namely the heads of the Magi and some rearing horses in the distance, yet it is clearly unfinished. Apart from areas of ground colour there is little else to give it depth or please the eye with harmony of hue. One despairs of so many of Leonardo's works that remain unfinished as tributes to his flawed genius.
I believe life should be worked upon as with any other expression of the human craving to produce perfection. A good life can be judged at any one time by its horizontal harmonies judged by relationships with family and friends, satisfaction with work or professional advancement and the capacity to enjoy leisure and recreation. Looking at life vertically a complete and balanced composition would include a time for childhood games, a time for education, a time for marriage and homebuilding, a time for the conception and raising of children, a time to hand over to the next generation, to retire and enjoy the fruits of one's labour and finally a time for a dignified death. Not all of us are capable of creating great works of art, but there is an art in the striving for achievement and even a tragically foreshortened life can leave beauty behind like an unfinished symphony.
My brother David
Let me remind you about my young brother David. He had a lean and hungry look crowned by a huge head of curly hair that made one think of Harpo Marx. He wore exuberant bow ties, did magic and was a deeply religious Jew, indeed a “Shomer Shabbat”. (literally meaning Guardian of the Sabbath). In contrast I am portly and balding, I wear normal ties and respect those laws of the Sabbath that suit me. We came from the same genetic pool but were of different phenotypes and yet in parts our brains seemed to have been hard- wired in a similar way. He was also a clinical scientist but a pediatrician. He was a fanatically hard worker and set the pace when we used to study together as undergraduates young post grads in Birmingham.
On his death he left behind him his wife Angela, an artist and four wonderful boys, Benjamin (Buzz), Joshua, Jacob and Samuel. It was only at his memorial service in Bristol attended by thousands, did I learn of all his achievements in promoting children’s health around the globe and the promotion of the hospice movement for children dying of cancer. He combined a zeal for life fueled by his faith and his candle burnt out prematurely flaming at both ends. But what a life, a masterpiece of a life, a life full of colour and perfect symmetry yet in many ways an unfinished symphony of a life. He never lived to enjoy that golden retirement he dreamed of, with him studying Talmud in Sefad with Angela painting by his side. The nearest he came to that was his burial plot in Rosh Pinah overlooking his beloved Kineret (The Sea of Galilee). Yet in his for-shortened life he achieved more than most could achieve if they lived to be 120.
The Rajastani Potter
In October 1994, my wife and I visited India to take in the UICC World Cancer Congress in New Delhi. We took advantage of this visit to enjoy a very comfortable and spectacular tour of the Golden Triangle in Rajasthan. On this visit I learnt that of the population of India, which numbers approximately one billion, seven hundred and fifty million live in abject poverty with a life expectancy thirty years less than our own. One cannot possibly begin to imagine the enormity of such numbers and once again it is necessary in order to gain the slightest of insights, to focus in on the life of a single individual. We enjoyed three magnificent days staying in the lap of luxury in the Lake Palace Hotel in Udaipur. On one of these days our guide took us through the hills and jungle north of Udaipur to visit the Jain Temples of Ranakpur. Along the way he made a diversion so that we could visit a small rural village where he was well known. Stopping at the side of a rutted and primitive road we continued our journey on foot through all kinds of excreta and rubbish past stagnant pools where the colourful women of Rajasthan were beating their saris clean; through a tumbledown village of mud-bricks and collapsing thatch to a little shed to watch the potter at his work. As always, I enjoyed the creation of an artifact out of formless clay. The potter enjoyed our interest and his wife and countless children were thrilled by the visit of alien creatures from what might have been another planet. Their interest and amusement with us, and the offers of hospitality were disarmingly genuine. This seemed to be a man, happy with the weft of his life strengthened by his family network and the beauty and utility of the objects he was creating. Also, from what I learned during my visit to India, the warp of his life was punctuated by Hindu festivals and rituals. Like many of the poor and uneducated in India, he was blissfully unaware of the alternative lifestyle enjoyed by us Westerners and so probably lacked the ambition to "improve himself" and had no desire for consumer durables or skiing holidays. I am well aware that it is easy to romanticize this squalor and look upon this harmless man as a “noble savage”, but just as we should try and improve on nature with finding a cure for cancer I believe it should be an expression of our humanity to improve upon nurture so that the health and welfare of this family could be improved. I cannot believe that his life would lose much of value if all his children had a good education and were able to realize their full potential and enjoy the artistic traditions of their own society. I don't believe anything of value would be lost by trying to reduce the appalling infant mortality by the simple expedient of providing fresh, uncontaminated running water and I cannot believe that much of value would be lost if the potter lived long enough to enjoy his grandchildren. This then leaves me with a troubling thought. Would India, or for that matter, the rest of the world, be a better place if there were fewer citizens with more complete lives. In other words is birth control and easy access to abortion the only answers to these questions. I certainly don't side with the pro- life fanatics in the United States of America. I can think of no greater obscenity than those who commit murder in the name of the unborn. I tend to side with the sardonic political commentator P J O'Rourke. In his book “All the Worlds Troubles” he points out with devastating logic that population density per se is not the cause of poverty and misery and emphasizes that certain areas of Southern California have a greater population density than the Delta area of Bangladesh. His explanation for the cause of poverty, misery and a high infant mortality is the direct correlation of these world troubles with nations that practice religious intolerance, feudalism and corruption.
Returning now to my metaphor of the weft and warp of life; I recognize that to describe life as a rich tapestry is a rather exhausted cliché, but it will serve my purpose now. A character in Somerset Maughan's lovely fable "A Moon and Sixpence", someone who is clearly a prototype hippy, carries with him at all times a rolled up Persian carpet. He uses this as a “memento vitae”. It had always been my ambition to emulate this character and one of the other great successes of our visit to India was to bring back a silken Kashmiri carpet. Due to some brilliant bargaining on behalf of my wife we were able to purchase this exquisite work of art at barely twice what it cost the vendor! Like all true Kashmiri silk carpets it is indeed magic. Viewed from my current position at my writing desk I can enjoy its robust and intricate patterns suggestive of the mathematics of a complex organism. The colours are vivid, rich and dark. Viewed from the other side, it takes on an entirely different character. The shades are pastel, the outlines of the design ephemeral and the carpet appears to float above the ground. Give me my current perspective of this carpet any day and let the metaphysicians enjoy the alternative viewpoint as much as they like, providing they don't impose their view of life on me by forced conversion, torture or decree.
Returning to the Case in Point
Let me now return to the case of the young woman twenty one weeks' pregnant with impending spinal cord compression from metastatic breast cancer. As an informed and carefully calculated choice she allowed the pregnancy to go to thirty two weeks before delivery through Caesarean section. This compromise allowed a new life into the world with an almost 100% chance of survival in health to adult life. This child is a reminder to her husband of his late wife. This child allows a beautiful symmetry in her for-shortened life denied on the previous occasion at the time of her initial diagnosis. I supported her in this decision from my own ethical standpoint because I was not actively shortening her life for the benefit of the child. This new life started at a disadvantage because of the limited life expectancy of the mother, but the starting point for all works of art are of an infinite variety and what could be a less promising subject than say Van Gough's shoes? Although as a Jew I will always value the life of a mother over the potential life of a foetus, I can recognize the persuasiveness of the argument that a potential life may be valued equally with the fully developed life of the adult.
------
20 years ago I suffered a severe bout of clinical depression. Only fellow sufferers will fully appreciate what this mean. That mood is certainly well illustrated in the passage from Macbeth quoted at the start of this chapter. No amount of reassurance from my family or friends could persuade me that I was of any worth and that my life had any meaning. Towards the end of this illness I experienced an episode that can only be described as a sunburst of happiness and in a crude attempt to emulate Van-Gough I described this feeling with a painting of sunflowers created with a palate knife and thick impasto. Although frightful at that time I think that period of illness was of enormous and lasting value to me. Many people live their life taking it for granted without truly valuing the gift. There is no better way of describing my attitude to life than by using the words of George Bernard Shaw whose feelings are the complete antithesis to those Shakespeare expressed through the mouth of Macbeth:
"This is the true joy in life, the being used for a purpose recognized by yourself as a mighty one, the being a force of nature instead of a feverish little clod of ailments and grievances complaining that the world will not devote itself to making you happy. I am of the opinion that my life belongs to the whole community, and as long as I live it is my privilege to do for it whatever I can. I want to be thoroughly used up when I die, for the harder I work the more I live. I rejoice in life for its own sake. Life is no brief candle to me. It is a sort of splendid torch which I have got hold of for the moment and I want to make it burn as brightly as possible before handing it on to future generations."
That was how my brother David lived his life and thus was the manner of his parting.
"Tomorrow and tomorrow and tomorrow creeps in this petty pace from day to day to the last syllable of recorded time and all our yesterdays have lighted fools the way to dusty death. Out, out brief candle! Life's but a walking shadow. A poor player that struts and frets his hour upon the stage until he is heard no more. It is a tale told by an idiot full of sound and fury signifying nothing."
Macbeth Act V Scene V.
I learnt this soliloquy from Macbeth by heart, at about the age of seven and used it as my "party piece" whenever my parents had the opportunity to show off their gifted children in front of an appreciative audience of family and friends. What my parents could never have predicted was the consequence of my sudden understanding of this bleak passage, when at about the age of eleven, I embarked on my lifelong career an insomniac. I remember clearly as a precocious young boy, lying awake all night trying to determine which was worse, to live forever, or to die at some uncertain point in the future and what was life all about anyway? Shakespeare's suggestion that it signified nothing added a new layer or terror to my troubled nights. However, with the passage of time my experience of life (and for that matter my experience of death), I think I've been able to define the questions with considerable more maturity than that of the pre-pubescent lad. I therefore welcomed the opportunity this memoir provides me with, to try to synthesize fifty years of self-questioning as to the meaning of life and the relevance of this to my clinical practice.
My attitude to the big question has been shaped by three major influences. These influences have been my upbringing as a Jew, my scientific curiosity as a practicing clinical scientist and my lifelong passionate affair with the visual arts. I don't think it’s any exaggeration or particular conceit to say that sometimes I have to draw on all these inner resources in counseling my patients to help them make difficult decisions that might influence both the length and quality of their lives.
In the quiet doldrums between Christmas and the end of the New Year holiday break in 1995, I was called in to help a young woman make one of the toughest choices that anyone can ever be called upon to decide.
In fact the decision reminded me of “Sophie’s choice” in William Styron’s tragic novel of the same name.
The young woman in question was a pretty Greek Orthodox girl aged thirty-one. Four years earlier she had been diagnosed with breast cancer at a time when she was twelve weeks pregnant. The pregnancy was terminated and she underwent a conventional course of treatment that involved surgery, radiotherapy and chemotherapy. She was very keen to start a family and I advised her to wait a year or two. It should be noted in passing that a pregnancy after breast cancer has been treated does not influence the prognosis, contrary to popular myth. At the time I was called in to advice, she was twenty -one weeks pregnant and had already felt the quickening of the baby in her womb. Tragically, she had also felt the symptoms of the secondary cancer in her spine. In addition to the severe pain that she experienced, she also described numbness and paresis affecting her left arm. Investigations demonstrated that there were metastases in the spine, compressing the spinal cord and the nerve roots to her left arm. The various therapeutic options we had to consider included surgery for immediate decompression of the spinal cord, radiotherapy to the vertebra and cytotoxic chemotherapy. To do nothing at that stage would have been unthinkable as without treatment she would have become paraplegic in about 48 hours. Yet, the most effective treatments to prevent this dreaded complication and to add to the length and quality to her remaining life, would compromise the health or viability of the baby in the womb. Whose life was of greater value and whose decision was it anyway? Was the potential life of the unborn more meaningful than prolonging the life of a young adult? I was hoping that her own religious beliefs would guide me in this tough decision, but when asked directly she confessed to being a lapsed Christian and asked me for all the facts so that she could make an informed choice. Amongst the difficult truths that I had to convey was the fact that with even the best of all treatments her expectation of life would be unlikely to exceed two years and therefore should she allow a new life into the world the baby would grow up motherless. There was clearly no correct answer to this dilemma and I will return to the conclusion of this sad story at the end of the chapter but first let me tell what influenced my advice.
Judaic Influences;
All we know for sure is this life and the history of other lives. Life after death is purely speculative and Jews do not believe that this life is a preparation for the afterlife. Yet in spite of that, there is an almost unspoken assumption amongst Jews that they will be rewarded for a virtuous life, after death. For example, the prayer in the house of mourning: "Have mercy upon him. Pardon all him transgressions for there is none righteous upon the earth who doeth only good and sinneth not. Remember unto him the righteousness that he wrought and let his reward be with him and his recompense before him - bestow upon him the abounding happiness that is treasured up for the righteous". And yet paradoxically, on leaving the house of mourning our greeting to the principle mourners is to wish them a long life. We believe that life is of infinite worth and as infinity cannot be split then every moment of a life is of infinite value. We are therefore commanded to strive to preserve and prolong life and to avoid hazardous activities that risk our lives (and that should include smoking). This also explains our contempt for the suicide bombers, those who send them on their way and those who worship them as martyrs.
There are of course, some mystical Chasidic sects who wish to explore the meaning of life and speculate on the afterlife, but mainstream Judaism accepts life as an end in itself and our religious teachings are primarily aimed at providing a code of conduct with more attention being paid to the relationships between man and man than between man and his God. Even to question whether life has a meaning may be a meaningless question to a Jew. If life is an end in itself then to question its meaning is as empty an exercise as to question the meaning of virtue, truth and beauty. If there is a meaning to life then it has to be beyond our comprehension however many subtle clues may pass across our consciousness. We are analogous to the fish trying to comprehend life on earth when all its fish-like brain can perceive are distorted two-dimensional images that appear in its firmament. I would even go further and suggest it is the ultimate in intellectual arrogance to "know" the answer to this question. I happen to note that there is a tendency amongst those who “know” with certainty, to impose their beliefs on others and this in my opinion is the source of most of the world's problems. This confident knowledge of the unknowable leads to religious fundamentalism, forced conversion, terrorism and the three horsemen of the apocalypse.
The Teachings of Biological Science
It is natural for human beings to see patterns in their life. For every effect they like to know the cause. For example, is cancer a punishment? Is it a fault of lifestyle? Is it in the family? Why me? For every patient therefore, there is an emotional need to understand a little about the nature of cancer if only to remove the guilt and the stigma, which has been associated with it in the past. The aetiology of cancer probably involves two basic steps: initiation, which may be a necessary but not sufficient cause, and a second set of events, which are described as promotional. Apart from the rare cases of genetic predisposition to cancer, initiating factors are exogenous (from without) whereas promotional factors are largely constitutional (from within). There are some obvious examples where clearly defined exogenous factors initiate the disease and where in theory prevention is possible. The best example of course is smoking and its impact on the incidence of lung cancer, bladder cancer and head and neck cancer. Another well established example of this kind is the association between malignant melanoma of the skin and the exposure of white races to excessive sunlight. It is likely that the initiation of the majority of common and for that matter, uncommon cancers are random events resulting from exogenous factors beyond our control leading to somatic mutations in the human genome. These may result from cosmic rays, radon from the granite of the earth or the low, persistent background of x-radiation. We assume that there are constant random mutations occurring within our genome, but we have exquisite repair mechanisms and to an extent our vulnerability to cancer may not be so much due to the exogenous factors as to inherent failures of our natural repair mechanisms. We are thus rapidly developing a mechanistic concept of the nature of cancer, which will ultimately lead to rational biological cures. In the meantime, we have to ask whether this increasing knowledge can help us understand cancer from the humanistic point of view. How can a cancer doctor retain any semblance of faith, which is tested each time he witnesses the suffering imposed by this dreadful disease. Paradoxically, each time I contemplate the micro-cosmos of the cancer cell, I find my faith restored. Of course it is commonplace to see God’s work in the cosmos as illustrated by the last paragraph of Stephen Hawking's best seller "A Brief History of Time": "There may be only one complete unified theory that is self-consistent and allow the existence of structures as complicated as human beings who can investigate the laws of the universe and ask about the nature of God. If we find the answer to that, it would be the ultimate triumph of human reason, for then we would know the mind of God". I enjoy the same sense of awe from the study of inner space rather than outer space. Watson and Crick discovered the structure of DNA in 1953 and subsequent biological scientists have come up with mind-boggling statistics as awe inspiring as those related to cosmology. Richard Dawkins puts it this way. There are 3 x 1012 cells in the body and 46 chromosomes per cell. 2 meters of DNA are packed into the nucleus of each cell tightly wound on these chromosomes. That is 6 x 1012 meters of DNA in each body, which is equivalent to the distance to the moon and back 8000 times! Each time the cell divides there is the hazard of a somatic mutation as a random event. Some cells divide every 48 hours. It is therefore a miracle to me that life can be sustained at all and the question "why me?" whenever someone develops cancer should be turned on its head and every day of everyone's life we should offer up a prayer that we didn't develop cancer in the previous 24 hours. Richard Dawkins in his most readable and mischievous book "The Blind Watchmaker" describes the fidelity of the transcription process beautifully and I wish to quote one of his passages at length: "DNA's performance as an archival medium is spectacular. In its capacity to preserve a message it far outdoes tablets of stone. Letters carved on gravestones become unreadable in mere hundreds of years. The DNA document is even more impressive, because unlike tablets of stone it is not the same physical structure that lasts and preserves the text. It is repeatedly being copied and recopied as the generations go by, like the Hebrew Scriptures, which were ritually copied by scribes every eighty years to forestall their wearing out. It is hard to estimate how many times the DNA document has been recopied in our lineage; probably as many as twenty billion times. It is hard to find a yardstick with which to compare the preservation of more than 99% of the information in twenty billion successive copying."
Such precision is miraculous. Life in the first place is miraculous and preservation of our species is miraculous. Cancer is the inevitable result of any instability within the human genome without which evolution would have been postponed. Cancer therefore is the inevitable result of the gift of life and the evolution of a species to its current state of self-awareness that allows it to ask such questions. We should therefore give thanks for this gift however brief the candle within our grasp. It is of course a mute point as to whom or what we give thanks. That is another question mischievously addressed by Richard Dawkins, in his book the God Delusion. That aside one could therefore say that in asking the question "What is the meaning of life?" we are effectively looking a gift horse in the mouth. It could then be argued why have I been wasting my time as a clinical scientist?
I have given you the biologist's reason to believe, which includes a belief in reason but I also believe in something transcendental (pace Dawkins) which encourages me challenge nature.
Lessons from the Study of Fine Art
If life is a miracle, a gift and an end in itself, how do we judge a good life and for how long should we try to extend that life. It is to address these fundamental questions that I have to turn to the arts for guidance. Great works of art, whether they are paintings, music or literature are judged by their capacity to illustrate, interpret and enhance life's experience. I would like to take this definition and use fine art itself as the metaphor to set the parameters for a good and appropriately lengthy life. When judging a great painting I look for harmony of composition, balance of colour and tone and its capacity to evoke emotions of joy or understanding, but even someone unschooled in the appreciation of fine art can recognize an unfinished work when he sees it. For example, Leonardo da Vinci's Adoration of the Kings in the Uffizi Gallery, Florence: this has perfect composition and perspective and certain areas are beautifully sketched in, namely the heads of the Magi and some rearing horses in the distance, yet it is clearly unfinished. Apart from areas of ground colour there is little else to give it depth or please the eye with harmony of hue. One despairs of so many of Leonardo's works that remain unfinished as tributes to his flawed genius.
I believe life should be worked upon as with any other expression of the human craving to produce perfection. A good life can be judged at any one time by its horizontal harmonies judged by relationships with family and friends, satisfaction with work or professional advancement and the capacity to enjoy leisure and recreation. Looking at life vertically a complete and balanced composition would include a time for childhood games, a time for education, a time for marriage and homebuilding, a time for the conception and raising of children, a time to hand over to the next generation, to retire and enjoy the fruits of one's labour and finally a time for a dignified death. Not all of us are capable of creating great works of art, but there is an art in the striving for achievement and even a tragically foreshortened life can leave beauty behind like an unfinished symphony.
My brother David
Let me remind you about my young brother David. He had a lean and hungry look crowned by a huge head of curly hair that made one think of Harpo Marx. He wore exuberant bow ties, did magic and was a deeply religious Jew, indeed a “Shomer Shabbat”. (literally meaning Guardian of the Sabbath). In contrast I am portly and balding, I wear normal ties and respect those laws of the Sabbath that suit me. We came from the same genetic pool but were of different phenotypes and yet in parts our brains seemed to have been hard- wired in a similar way. He was also a clinical scientist but a pediatrician. He was a fanatically hard worker and set the pace when we used to study together as undergraduates young post grads in Birmingham.
On his death he left behind him his wife Angela, an artist and four wonderful boys, Benjamin (Buzz), Joshua, Jacob and Samuel. It was only at his memorial service in Bristol attended by thousands, did I learn of all his achievements in promoting children’s health around the globe and the promotion of the hospice movement for children dying of cancer. He combined a zeal for life fueled by his faith and his candle burnt out prematurely flaming at both ends. But what a life, a masterpiece of a life, a life full of colour and perfect symmetry yet in many ways an unfinished symphony of a life. He never lived to enjoy that golden retirement he dreamed of, with him studying Talmud in Sefad with Angela painting by his side. The nearest he came to that was his burial plot in Rosh Pinah overlooking his beloved Kineret (The Sea of Galilee). Yet in his for-shortened life he achieved more than most could achieve if they lived to be 120.
The Rajastani Potter
In October 1994, my wife and I visited India to take in the UICC World Cancer Congress in New Delhi. We took advantage of this visit to enjoy a very comfortable and spectacular tour of the Golden Triangle in Rajasthan. On this visit I learnt that of the population of India, which numbers approximately one billion, seven hundred and fifty million live in abject poverty with a life expectancy thirty years less than our own. One cannot possibly begin to imagine the enormity of such numbers and once again it is necessary in order to gain the slightest of insights, to focus in on the life of a single individual. We enjoyed three magnificent days staying in the lap of luxury in the Lake Palace Hotel in Udaipur. On one of these days our guide took us through the hills and jungle north of Udaipur to visit the Jain Temples of Ranakpur. Along the way he made a diversion so that we could visit a small rural village where he was well known. Stopping at the side of a rutted and primitive road we continued our journey on foot through all kinds of excreta and rubbish past stagnant pools where the colourful women of Rajasthan were beating their saris clean; through a tumbledown village of mud-bricks and collapsing thatch to a little shed to watch the potter at his work. As always, I enjoyed the creation of an artifact out of formless clay. The potter enjoyed our interest and his wife and countless children were thrilled by the visit of alien creatures from what might have been another planet. Their interest and amusement with us, and the offers of hospitality were disarmingly genuine. This seemed to be a man, happy with the weft of his life strengthened by his family network and the beauty and utility of the objects he was creating. Also, from what I learned during my visit to India, the warp of his life was punctuated by Hindu festivals and rituals. Like many of the poor and uneducated in India, he was blissfully unaware of the alternative lifestyle enjoyed by us Westerners and so probably lacked the ambition to "improve himself" and had no desire for consumer durables or skiing holidays. I am well aware that it is easy to romanticize this squalor and look upon this harmless man as a “noble savage”, but just as we should try and improve on nature with finding a cure for cancer I believe it should be an expression of our humanity to improve upon nurture so that the health and welfare of this family could be improved. I cannot believe that his life would lose much of value if all his children had a good education and were able to realize their full potential and enjoy the artistic traditions of their own society. I don't believe anything of value would be lost by trying to reduce the appalling infant mortality by the simple expedient of providing fresh, uncontaminated running water and I cannot believe that much of value would be lost if the potter lived long enough to enjoy his grandchildren. This then leaves me with a troubling thought. Would India, or for that matter, the rest of the world, be a better place if there were fewer citizens with more complete lives. In other words is birth control and easy access to abortion the only answers to these questions. I certainly don't side with the pro- life fanatics in the United States of America. I can think of no greater obscenity than those who commit murder in the name of the unborn. I tend to side with the sardonic political commentator P J O'Rourke. In his book “All the Worlds Troubles” he points out with devastating logic that population density per se is not the cause of poverty and misery and emphasizes that certain areas of Southern California have a greater population density than the Delta area of Bangladesh. His explanation for the cause of poverty, misery and a high infant mortality is the direct correlation of these world troubles with nations that practice religious intolerance, feudalism and corruption.
Returning now to my metaphor of the weft and warp of life; I recognize that to describe life as a rich tapestry is a rather exhausted cliché, but it will serve my purpose now. A character in Somerset Maughan's lovely fable "A Moon and Sixpence", someone who is clearly a prototype hippy, carries with him at all times a rolled up Persian carpet. He uses this as a “memento vitae”. It had always been my ambition to emulate this character and one of the other great successes of our visit to India was to bring back a silken Kashmiri carpet. Due to some brilliant bargaining on behalf of my wife we were able to purchase this exquisite work of art at barely twice what it cost the vendor! Like all true Kashmiri silk carpets it is indeed magic. Viewed from my current position at my writing desk I can enjoy its robust and intricate patterns suggestive of the mathematics of a complex organism. The colours are vivid, rich and dark. Viewed from the other side, it takes on an entirely different character. The shades are pastel, the outlines of the design ephemeral and the carpet appears to float above the ground. Give me my current perspective of this carpet any day and let the metaphysicians enjoy the alternative viewpoint as much as they like, providing they don't impose their view of life on me by forced conversion, torture or decree.
Returning to the Case in Point
Let me now return to the case of the young woman twenty one weeks' pregnant with impending spinal cord compression from metastatic breast cancer. As an informed and carefully calculated choice she allowed the pregnancy to go to thirty two weeks before delivery through Caesarean section. This compromise allowed a new life into the world with an almost 100% chance of survival in health to adult life. This child is a reminder to her husband of his late wife. This child allows a beautiful symmetry in her for-shortened life denied on the previous occasion at the time of her initial diagnosis. I supported her in this decision from my own ethical standpoint because I was not actively shortening her life for the benefit of the child. This new life started at a disadvantage because of the limited life expectancy of the mother, but the starting point for all works of art are of an infinite variety and what could be a less promising subject than say Van Gough's shoes? Although as a Jew I will always value the life of a mother over the potential life of a foetus, I can recognize the persuasiveness of the argument that a potential life may be valued equally with the fully developed life of the adult.
------
20 years ago I suffered a severe bout of clinical depression. Only fellow sufferers will fully appreciate what this mean. That mood is certainly well illustrated in the passage from Macbeth quoted at the start of this chapter. No amount of reassurance from my family or friends could persuade me that I was of any worth and that my life had any meaning. Towards the end of this illness I experienced an episode that can only be described as a sunburst of happiness and in a crude attempt to emulate Van-Gough I described this feeling with a painting of sunflowers created with a palate knife and thick impasto. Although frightful at that time I think that period of illness was of enormous and lasting value to me. Many people live their life taking it for granted without truly valuing the gift. There is no better way of describing my attitude to life than by using the words of George Bernard Shaw whose feelings are the complete antithesis to those Shakespeare expressed through the mouth of Macbeth:
"This is the true joy in life, the being used for a purpose recognized by yourself as a mighty one, the being a force of nature instead of a feverish little clod of ailments and grievances complaining that the world will not devote itself to making you happy. I am of the opinion that my life belongs to the whole community, and as long as I live it is my privilege to do for it whatever I can. I want to be thoroughly used up when I die, for the harder I work the more I live. I rejoice in life for its own sake. Life is no brief candle to me. It is a sort of splendid torch which I have got hold of for the moment and I want to make it burn as brightly as possible before handing it on to future generations."
That was how my brother David lived his life and thus was the manner of his parting.
Saturday, 16 June 2007
Chapter 1

The Importance of Symmetry
Each morning on waking, I get out of bed, turn to my right 90 degrees and find my slippers arranged in perfect symmetry side by side, toes pointing to the mid point of the bed-side table waiting to slide onto my early morning feet. For some reason Judy, my wife, finds this extremely irritating and when making the bed might accidentally on purpose disturb this perfect symmetry with a well placed kick. The curious thing is that I never have any recall of arranging my slippers in this way and yet every morning there they are waiting for me. You may think that’s all you need to know about me. Clearly I’m a bigot and an obsessional neurotic. This was indeed the message contained in a scene of the film “The Dead Poets Society” starring Robin Williams. The protagonist played by Mr. Williams was a free thinking maverick school teacher who ripped pages from text-books, taught his students to “seize the day” and express their inner self through literature and poetry. The “bad guy” was the father of one of the boys who objected to his son writing poetry and wanting to be an actor when he was destined to join his father’s business. He eventually drove his son to suicide and the Robin Williams character was driven out of his job. The “bigoted” father put his slippers on just the way I do and this was shown in close up in order to fix the stereotype. I’m also obsessionaly tidy in my work practices. My office table is usually cleaned up at the end of each day and any books or papers I’m working from are left beautifully squared off in line with the desktop and arranged in pyramidal piles, largest at the base smallest at the top, looking like a miniature model of the Aztec site outside Mexico City. The desk in my clinic is the same and if I don’t see each patient on time I get wound up inside as tight as a watch spring. Like John Cleese in the film “Clockwise”, I always try to get there on time. If we have a party to go to that starts at 8.00pm, even if it is the other side of London I always arrive with a chronological precision that even I find uncanny. For some reason my wife finds this habit intensely irritating as well. I must be hard to live with, I’m even hard on myself, yet I can’t be all bad as Judy and I have been together for over 40 years and we never row, something else she finds annoying.
Clearly there is an obsessional trait in my character but I would like to say in my defense that part of my love of symmetry is aesthetic in origin. One of my passions in life is fine art and I paint a bit too. I’m often drawn to paintings in ways I don’t at first understand. For example I’ve just finished a reworking of Vermeer’s “Woman holding a balance”. I’ve replaced the pearls that she is weighing with double strands of DNA that also appears in the painting on the wall behind her head in place of the “The Last Judgment”, re naming the painting “The Genetic Test”. Only after hours of intense scrutiny, did I notice that the fulcrum of the balance that she holds so daintily in her right hand is precisely at the point where the diagonals of the rectangle of the canvas cross. Furthermore if you then follow this point up to the top of the picture and then drop a vertical down to the table top you find you are at the 6 o’clock position of a perfect arc described by a string of pearls looping across the table and the pensive young woman’s left arm. That observation gave me as much satisfaction as any scientific discovery. (See figure 1)
I’m not quite sure if I was drawn to surgery as a result of this personality trait or whether the years of strict discipline in the operating theatre drove me this way. Certainly many of my colleagues share this behavior. I love the calm and order in the OR, everything and everyone knowing their place; the instrument tray gleaming with stainless steel reflecting the powerful operating theatre lights, all the instruments lined up in order of size with the consultant surgeon as captain of this tight ship. No room for democracy in the operating theatre! The ritual of scrubbing up and laying on of drapes is like some druidical ceremony. Even the colors of the brilliant carmine red of the arterial blood against the green of the drapes are aesthetically pleasing on the eye. Finally no operation is complete until the wound is neatly dressed and the whole area clean and sparkling again. Just like my desktop at the end of the day.
This love of symmetry and order extends to the way I view my very existence. For example the urge to write this book was not as an ego trip but as a way of achieving closure on the penultimate chapter of my life following my retirement from the NHS and my chair of surgery. However an even more perfect example of my search for one of life’s symmetries was provided by chance in 2001 with an invitation to speak at a conference in Warsaw, precisely 100 years after my father’s birth in that city.
I was warmly greeted at the airport by two of my hosts. I responded with equal warmth not sure if I had met them before. What’s there to lose? Part of the problem of being a minor “celebrity” on the lecture circuit, is that you meet thousands of folk on standing down from the podium and with the best will in the world, you may remember faces and even names but to put the two together especially when disorientated by foreign travel is beyond my intelligence. Curiously my wife has that gift but on this occasion wasn’t there to help me out. The day was overcast and gray with a threat of snow and my spirits sank as I was driven through ugly gray suburbs laid out on a bleak flat landscape. My hotel was aesthetically challenged and my room, the best available for the visiting “celebrity”, was as bare and charmless as a student’s hostel. There was no chair, the light was missing from a bare wire dangling from the ceiling, the pillow was wafer thin (this did not bode well for someone who suffers from reflux oesophagitis), there was no plug in the sink and the soap provided was the size and shape of an “after eight” mint. At last, I thought, I’m appearing in a David Lodge campus novel. I revived my spirits a little with a slug of cask strength Glenfarclas I’d wisely bought at Heathrow and consoled myself by thinking that at least on this occasion my wife wasn’t with me to winge. Things could only get better and they did. That evening I was driven into the old center of the city for dinner. Next to Sao Paolo in Brazil, Warsaw is the ugliest city I’ve visited. It consists mainly of gray cube like apartments that we have come to associate with the workers paradise of the former Soviet Union. The only building of note as you enter the downtown area is the huge tower of the Peoples Palace of Culture a gift of Stalin to the workers of Poland. The grandiose overbearing tower, that looks as if it was built from giant size Lego blocks is typical of the Stalinist architecture of the 1950s and is an affront to the artistic eye. My Polish hosts were clearly embarrassed by it, as they seemed to be with any discussion of the Soviet period of their history. Things started to get better as we left our cars in the old central square and made our way to the evening’s venue. Now it must be remembered that before Warsaw fell to the Russians, the German’s razed it to the ground. In one of the most ignoble episodes of the second world war the Russians stood by on the East bank of the Vistula, whilst allowing the Nazis to crush the Polish uprising, in order to allow the leadership of the resistance movement to be liquidated without having to do it themselves. This destruction included the beautiful 16thC central zone, which has now been painstakingly restored to its original appearance. This has been done with such skill that there is no suggestion of an EPCOT like theme park; it truly looks old. The restaurant was in the barrel-roofed cellar of an old town house full of character and charm as was my dinner companion Dr. Anna Niwinska, although she was a lot younger. Two glasses of special vodka later I was becoming animated, pledging fraternal toasts to my right and my left.
Two more glasses and I was becoming maudlin telling everyone within earshot about the suffering of my late father as a boy in Warsaw, tearfully asking if it would be possible to visit his birthplace on the meager information I could supply.
Then the food came in which I instantly recognized as my late mother’s cuisine. Heavy dumplings in barley soup, calf’s foot jelly, cholent simmered for 24 hours and noodle with raisin pudding for desert. I felt full of contentment and bittersweet memories of my lovely mother who devoted her life to her family, preparing meals like an angel only to die a painful death from breast cancer at the very age I sit writing. After a few more vodka toasts the world went a little fuzzy at the edges and the next morning I woke to find that my slippers were not in their right place.
After two strong cups of coffee I prepared myself for the main event. I was first to chair a session and then aided by simultaneous translation, to deliver a keynote lecture on my latest clinical research together with philosophical musings on the nature of conceptual models of disease. This seemed to go down well although my witticisms seemed to lose something in translation. I also avoided falling into the trap of patronizing my eastern European audience. For a start the chairman of my session, Professor Jacek Jassem from Gdansk was President of the European Breast Cancer Conference that year and Marie Curie had started her pioneering work on radium just round the corner. In fact one of the most wonderful products of the fall of the Soviet Empire is the welcoming of many nations with a great scientific tradition back into the bosom of the international scientific community.
The standard of the meeting as a whole was worthy of their heritage and their hospitality overwhelming. The rest of the meeting fell into a pattern, which I had long come to recognize and enjoy. Speakers dinner the first night, a typical folklorist show the second and the inevitable “gala dinner” mit muzik on the last.
The show was somewhat unusual entitled “Musicale, Ach te Musicale” at the teatrze Roma. It consisted of exerts from popular musicals translated into Polish.
“My Fair Lady” was a hoot with something definitely lost in translation during the “I’m getting married in the morning” song which came out sounding like “Orang- ootang murdered in the bath tub” but that didn’t stop me singing along with the cast. But the next number stopped me in my tracks and had me blubbing into my hankerchief. On came Tevya from “Fiddler on the roof” to sing, “If I was a rich man da –da- da- da- da –da- da- daya”. He was bearded and dressed in a garb like the sepia photographs of my paternal grand father. So here I was a Londoner in Warsaw watching a Polish translation of an American musical which was meant to be an evocation of the stetl (village) life from which my family escaped first to the big city of Warsaw and then to London. Would my grandfather have been proud? I doubt it because along the way I had shed the mantel of the Chassidic Jew and was here in a completely secular role.
The next day of lectures and debates was followed by the “Gala dinner”. After the food and the toasts, I went easy on the vodka this time; the joint began to jump to the beat of rhythm and blues. To start with I watched wistfully from the sidelines as the pretty young doctors and their young bucks took to the floor and boogied to the beat. I love dancing and used to be quite good, in fact I won the Mister Twister competition in 1961 whilst a house officer at the Birmingham General Hospital. Perhaps feeling sorry for me a gorgeous blond medical oncologist dragged me on to the floor and I boogied with the best of them. Suddenly I had a rare moment of self-revelation and saw myself as a sad, rotund, past his sell by date old professor. I took my leave and went early to bed the bitter self revelation, the alcohol and rich food combined with the flat pillow guaranteeing a night of heartburn and insomnia.
My last day in Warsaw was given over to sightseeing and on this occasion my guides were the same Dr.Anna Niwinska and Professor Andrzej Kulakowski, director of the Maria Sklodowska-Curie Memorial Cancer Center. Professor Kulakowski was born in 1929 and served with the Polish resistance during the uprising in 1943-44. As a boy of 14 he ran backwards and forwards delivering ammunition to the besieged fighters narrowly missing death on many occasions. He went on to become Poland’s leading surgical oncologist. The first stop on my tour was Marie Curie’s office to view her memorabilia and to be presented with a memorial medal. After that we made the pilgrimage to the memorial of the Warsaw Ghetto uprising, a noble and awe -inspiring monument raised by the Poles in admiration for the heroism of the Jewish fighters. One of the few survivors was a baby girl smuggled out in a shoebox. I met her last year at a charity event in Frankfurt. She is the wife of the President of the vibrant young Jewish community there. I offered up my prayers and shed a few more tears getting more lachrymose by the minute. I was then taken to the Saxony gardens mentioned in my father’s memoirs and finally as a coup de grace to the environs of my father’s birthplace. Much to my delight and great surprise Anna had taken note of my vodka fuelled ramblings of the first night and together with Professor Kulakowski, who knew the city like the back of his hand both before and after its destruction, were able to carry out some detective work and with the aid of an old map had traced the junction of Genshe street described to me by my father, to an area that used to be in the Ghetto. The only building left standing after the Nazis had finished was the Church of the Nativity of the Virgin Mary. After the Russians had moved in they rebuilt the area retaining the old grid of roads, with brutal concrete workers apartments. The roads were renamed after Soviet heroes. Standing at the corner of Anielewicza and Karlmelika we ran out of clues and were about to leave it at that when a bent old babushka of 80 plus years emerged from her ground floor flat. She had total recall of the topography of that area having served nearby as a maid in the pre war years. Her claw like hand took mine and dragged me one block away where she pointed “Genshe, Genshe!” I gave her all my Zlotys and on my mobile, phoned my oldest brother Geoffrey to tell him that I had traced our roots. Roots schmoots, if my grandfather hadn’t taken the initiative to leave Warsaw in 1912 I wouldn’t be here today, but at least my need for symmetry was satisfied.
Each morning on waking, I get out of bed, turn to my right 90 degrees and find my slippers arranged in perfect symmetry side by side, toes pointing to the mid point of the bed-side table waiting to slide onto my early morning feet. For some reason Judy, my wife, finds this extremely irritating and when making the bed might accidentally on purpose disturb this perfect symmetry with a well placed kick. The curious thing is that I never have any recall of arranging my slippers in this way and yet every morning there they are waiting for me. You may think that’s all you need to know about me. Clearly I’m a bigot and an obsessional neurotic. This was indeed the message contained in a scene of the film “The Dead Poets Society” starring Robin Williams. The protagonist played by Mr. Williams was a free thinking maverick school teacher who ripped pages from text-books, taught his students to “seize the day” and express their inner self through literature and poetry. The “bad guy” was the father of one of the boys who objected to his son writing poetry and wanting to be an actor when he was destined to join his father’s business. He eventually drove his son to suicide and the Robin Williams character was driven out of his job. The “bigoted” father put his slippers on just the way I do and this was shown in close up in order to fix the stereotype. I’m also obsessionaly tidy in my work practices. My office table is usually cleaned up at the end of each day and any books or papers I’m working from are left beautifully squared off in line with the desktop and arranged in pyramidal piles, largest at the base smallest at the top, looking like a miniature model of the Aztec site outside Mexico City. The desk in my clinic is the same and if I don’t see each patient on time I get wound up inside as tight as a watch spring. Like John Cleese in the film “Clockwise”, I always try to get there on time. If we have a party to go to that starts at 8.00pm, even if it is the other side of London I always arrive with a chronological precision that even I find uncanny. For some reason my wife finds this habit intensely irritating as well. I must be hard to live with, I’m even hard on myself, yet I can’t be all bad as Judy and I have been together for over 40 years and we never row, something else she finds annoying.
Clearly there is an obsessional trait in my character but I would like to say in my defense that part of my love of symmetry is aesthetic in origin. One of my passions in life is fine art and I paint a bit too. I’m often drawn to paintings in ways I don’t at first understand. For example I’ve just finished a reworking of Vermeer’s “Woman holding a balance”. I’ve replaced the pearls that she is weighing with double strands of DNA that also appears in the painting on the wall behind her head in place of the “The Last Judgment”, re naming the painting “The Genetic Test”. Only after hours of intense scrutiny, did I notice that the fulcrum of the balance that she holds so daintily in her right hand is precisely at the point where the diagonals of the rectangle of the canvas cross. Furthermore if you then follow this point up to the top of the picture and then drop a vertical down to the table top you find you are at the 6 o’clock position of a perfect arc described by a string of pearls looping across the table and the pensive young woman’s left arm. That observation gave me as much satisfaction as any scientific discovery. (See figure 1)
I’m not quite sure if I was drawn to surgery as a result of this personality trait or whether the years of strict discipline in the operating theatre drove me this way. Certainly many of my colleagues share this behavior. I love the calm and order in the OR, everything and everyone knowing their place; the instrument tray gleaming with stainless steel reflecting the powerful operating theatre lights, all the instruments lined up in order of size with the consultant surgeon as captain of this tight ship. No room for democracy in the operating theatre! The ritual of scrubbing up and laying on of drapes is like some druidical ceremony. Even the colors of the brilliant carmine red of the arterial blood against the green of the drapes are aesthetically pleasing on the eye. Finally no operation is complete until the wound is neatly dressed and the whole area clean and sparkling again. Just like my desktop at the end of the day.
This love of symmetry and order extends to the way I view my very existence. For example the urge to write this book was not as an ego trip but as a way of achieving closure on the penultimate chapter of my life following my retirement from the NHS and my chair of surgery. However an even more perfect example of my search for one of life’s symmetries was provided by chance in 2001 with an invitation to speak at a conference in Warsaw, precisely 100 years after my father’s birth in that city.
I was warmly greeted at the airport by two of my hosts. I responded with equal warmth not sure if I had met them before. What’s there to lose? Part of the problem of being a minor “celebrity” on the lecture circuit, is that you meet thousands of folk on standing down from the podium and with the best will in the world, you may remember faces and even names but to put the two together especially when disorientated by foreign travel is beyond my intelligence. Curiously my wife has that gift but on this occasion wasn’t there to help me out. The day was overcast and gray with a threat of snow and my spirits sank as I was driven through ugly gray suburbs laid out on a bleak flat landscape. My hotel was aesthetically challenged and my room, the best available for the visiting “celebrity”, was as bare and charmless as a student’s hostel. There was no chair, the light was missing from a bare wire dangling from the ceiling, the pillow was wafer thin (this did not bode well for someone who suffers from reflux oesophagitis), there was no plug in the sink and the soap provided was the size and shape of an “after eight” mint. At last, I thought, I’m appearing in a David Lodge campus novel. I revived my spirits a little with a slug of cask strength Glenfarclas I’d wisely bought at Heathrow and consoled myself by thinking that at least on this occasion my wife wasn’t with me to winge. Things could only get better and they did. That evening I was driven into the old center of the city for dinner. Next to Sao Paolo in Brazil, Warsaw is the ugliest city I’ve visited. It consists mainly of gray cube like apartments that we have come to associate with the workers paradise of the former Soviet Union. The only building of note as you enter the downtown area is the huge tower of the Peoples Palace of Culture a gift of Stalin to the workers of Poland. The grandiose overbearing tower, that looks as if it was built from giant size Lego blocks is typical of the Stalinist architecture of the 1950s and is an affront to the artistic eye. My Polish hosts were clearly embarrassed by it, as they seemed to be with any discussion of the Soviet period of their history. Things started to get better as we left our cars in the old central square and made our way to the evening’s venue. Now it must be remembered that before Warsaw fell to the Russians, the German’s razed it to the ground. In one of the most ignoble episodes of the second world war the Russians stood by on the East bank of the Vistula, whilst allowing the Nazis to crush the Polish uprising, in order to allow the leadership of the resistance movement to be liquidated without having to do it themselves. This destruction included the beautiful 16thC central zone, which has now been painstakingly restored to its original appearance. This has been done with such skill that there is no suggestion of an EPCOT like theme park; it truly looks old. The restaurant was in the barrel-roofed cellar of an old town house full of character and charm as was my dinner companion Dr. Anna Niwinska, although she was a lot younger. Two glasses of special vodka later I was becoming animated, pledging fraternal toasts to my right and my left.
Two more glasses and I was becoming maudlin telling everyone within earshot about the suffering of my late father as a boy in Warsaw, tearfully asking if it would be possible to visit his birthplace on the meager information I could supply.
Then the food came in which I instantly recognized as my late mother’s cuisine. Heavy dumplings in barley soup, calf’s foot jelly, cholent simmered for 24 hours and noodle with raisin pudding for desert. I felt full of contentment and bittersweet memories of my lovely mother who devoted her life to her family, preparing meals like an angel only to die a painful death from breast cancer at the very age I sit writing. After a few more vodka toasts the world went a little fuzzy at the edges and the next morning I woke to find that my slippers were not in their right place.
After two strong cups of coffee I prepared myself for the main event. I was first to chair a session and then aided by simultaneous translation, to deliver a keynote lecture on my latest clinical research together with philosophical musings on the nature of conceptual models of disease. This seemed to go down well although my witticisms seemed to lose something in translation. I also avoided falling into the trap of patronizing my eastern European audience. For a start the chairman of my session, Professor Jacek Jassem from Gdansk was President of the European Breast Cancer Conference that year and Marie Curie had started her pioneering work on radium just round the corner. In fact one of the most wonderful products of the fall of the Soviet Empire is the welcoming of many nations with a great scientific tradition back into the bosom of the international scientific community.
The standard of the meeting as a whole was worthy of their heritage and their hospitality overwhelming. The rest of the meeting fell into a pattern, which I had long come to recognize and enjoy. Speakers dinner the first night, a typical folklorist show the second and the inevitable “gala dinner” mit muzik on the last.
The show was somewhat unusual entitled “Musicale, Ach te Musicale” at the teatrze Roma. It consisted of exerts from popular musicals translated into Polish.
“My Fair Lady” was a hoot with something definitely lost in translation during the “I’m getting married in the morning” song which came out sounding like “Orang- ootang murdered in the bath tub” but that didn’t stop me singing along with the cast. But the next number stopped me in my tracks and had me blubbing into my hankerchief. On came Tevya from “Fiddler on the roof” to sing, “If I was a rich man da –da- da- da- da –da- da- daya”. He was bearded and dressed in a garb like the sepia photographs of my paternal grand father. So here I was a Londoner in Warsaw watching a Polish translation of an American musical which was meant to be an evocation of the stetl (village) life from which my family escaped first to the big city of Warsaw and then to London. Would my grandfather have been proud? I doubt it because along the way I had shed the mantel of the Chassidic Jew and was here in a completely secular role.
The next day of lectures and debates was followed by the “Gala dinner”. After the food and the toasts, I went easy on the vodka this time; the joint began to jump to the beat of rhythm and blues. To start with I watched wistfully from the sidelines as the pretty young doctors and their young bucks took to the floor and boogied to the beat. I love dancing and used to be quite good, in fact I won the Mister Twister competition in 1961 whilst a house officer at the Birmingham General Hospital. Perhaps feeling sorry for me a gorgeous blond medical oncologist dragged me on to the floor and I boogied with the best of them. Suddenly I had a rare moment of self-revelation and saw myself as a sad, rotund, past his sell by date old professor. I took my leave and went early to bed the bitter self revelation, the alcohol and rich food combined with the flat pillow guaranteeing a night of heartburn and insomnia.
My last day in Warsaw was given over to sightseeing and on this occasion my guides were the same Dr.Anna Niwinska and Professor Andrzej Kulakowski, director of the Maria Sklodowska-Curie Memorial Cancer Center. Professor Kulakowski was born in 1929 and served with the Polish resistance during the uprising in 1943-44. As a boy of 14 he ran backwards and forwards delivering ammunition to the besieged fighters narrowly missing death on many occasions. He went on to become Poland’s leading surgical oncologist. The first stop on my tour was Marie Curie’s office to view her memorabilia and to be presented with a memorial medal. After that we made the pilgrimage to the memorial of the Warsaw Ghetto uprising, a noble and awe -inspiring monument raised by the Poles in admiration for the heroism of the Jewish fighters. One of the few survivors was a baby girl smuggled out in a shoebox. I met her last year at a charity event in Frankfurt. She is the wife of the President of the vibrant young Jewish community there. I offered up my prayers and shed a few more tears getting more lachrymose by the minute. I was then taken to the Saxony gardens mentioned in my father’s memoirs and finally as a coup de grace to the environs of my father’s birthplace. Much to my delight and great surprise Anna had taken note of my vodka fuelled ramblings of the first night and together with Professor Kulakowski, who knew the city like the back of his hand both before and after its destruction, were able to carry out some detective work and with the aid of an old map had traced the junction of Genshe street described to me by my father, to an area that used to be in the Ghetto. The only building left standing after the Nazis had finished was the Church of the Nativity of the Virgin Mary. After the Russians had moved in they rebuilt the area retaining the old grid of roads, with brutal concrete workers apartments. The roads were renamed after Soviet heroes. Standing at the corner of Anielewicza and Karlmelika we ran out of clues and were about to leave it at that when a bent old babushka of 80 plus years emerged from her ground floor flat. She had total recall of the topography of that area having served nearby as a maid in the pre war years. Her claw like hand took mine and dragged me one block away where she pointed “Genshe, Genshe!” I gave her all my Zlotys and on my mobile, phoned my oldest brother Geoffrey to tell him that I had traced our roots. Roots schmoots, if my grandfather hadn’t taken the initiative to leave Warsaw in 1912 I wouldn’t be here today, but at least my need for symmetry was satisfied.
Chapter 2
Mostly about Mum
The first time I guessed that something was wrong with my mother was when I noticed her clasping her lower back in pain whilst climbing upstairs in front of me. This was in about 1972 on one of my rare visits home during my period of living in Cardiff and the image is burnt in my memory as a result of what was to follow. My mother was extremely stoical and never complained about ill health. Following on my enquiry, she claimed that it was her “rheumatism” playing up. I thought no more about it until about three months later when she was admitted to hospital to have her gall bladder removed because of stones and increasing pains in the region just below the ribs on the right. This was in no way alarming or for that matter surprising, as she fitted the stereotype. She was female, overweight and over forty. In addition she was constantly munching “Rennies” for heartburn, presumably due to reflux oesophagitis (a condition I inherited with a vengeance), that tends to co-exist with gall stones. The operation went all right and she did indeed have chronic gall stones; however in the post operative phase she developed agonizing pain spreading round from her mid lumbar region to the upper abdomen. X rays of her spine showed a crush fracture of the first lumbar vertebra and suspicion of skeletal secondaries from an unsuspected cancer. A rapid and more thorough clinical examination revealed an advanced cancer in her right breast. She was told not to worry as this was only “chronic mastitis” but my father was contacted immediately and told the grim news. My dad then contacted his five children, three of whom were medically qualified, to pass on the news, and begged us not to let on to mum that she had cancer that had spread round the body. To my lasting shame I concurred with this charade. Opiates were the only way of controlling her pain in the short term although radiotherapy to the spine provided more lasting benefit. The chemotherapy was harsh, causing nausea, vomiting, fatigue and the permanent loss of her long glossy black hair. I was not aware of any benefit from this cruel cocktail. After about twelve months the pains started up again and became more and more difficult to control. It reached the point when, according to erroneous belief at the time, that adequate analgesia would suppress her breathing and accelerate her demise, escalating doses of opiates were denied her. At this point the family gathered in London and my opinion was sought. I couldn’t bear the sight of her in pain and yet the Jewish teaching was clear on this point; as life is of infinite worth and as you cannot split infinity, then every moment of life was of equal value. She therefore continued to suffer until neither she nor the family could take any more and she died within 6 hours of a dose of morphine that adequately controlled her pain. She died on my 37th birthday, May 31st 1974.
The Jewish tradition has it that the dead must be buried within 24 hours and until then the body must not be left alone. I spent the nightlong vigil with my father and had plenty of time to confront my conscience, firstly for not having done enough to help her and secondly for not having demonstrating a son’s love at the time she needed it most.
Every mother loves her sons unconditionally but the return of such love by a son is often conditional and context dependent. At the time of my mother’s terminal illness I was very self absorbed. My duties as a senior lecturer/consultant surgeon at the University Hospital of Wales were onerous and occupied me for about ten hours a day not counting a one in three rota for night time emergencies. I was very ambitious, setting up research programmes, raising grants and keeping my eyes open for the chance of a professorial appointment. I often worked all week ends keeping up to date with the medical journals, writing manuscripts and dealing with correspondence. What little time I had left was lavished on my wife and three children under 7. I had no more space for love beyond this narrow circle and resented the distraction of my mother’s illness at the time. I loved her as a dependent child, was embarrassed by her hats on parent’s day when I was a school boy, had little time for her as a young professional but came to admire and yes, love her most of all, in retrospect, since her death.
My mother was a true ayshet chayil, who dedicated her whole life to the family, the most selfless person I have ever known. During the dark days of the war, the blitz and rationing, she looked after four children of her own (my sister was born after the war) together with other orphans, waifs and strays. From negligible resources she conjured up spectacular haimishe meals, made her own cream cheese, lokshen ( noodles) and kichelers (biscuits) from basic raw materials. In the absence of any household appliances she boiled all the linen in a great bubbling cauldron of a tub, extracted the last mote of dirt from the wet clothing and bed sheets on a scrubbing board, squeezed out the water in a huge mangle like a primitive printing press and hung it all out to dry either in the roof on a pulley system or if the weather was fine on a line in the yard. The heavy pre-modern irons were heated on the hot surface of the range (a pre-modern kind of Aga) and heaved on to the ironing board that was in constant use. Her obsessional personality (something else I’ve also inherited with a vengeance) meant that everything had to be folded and filed away in its place before she collapsed into bed after midnight. By the time I rose in the morning, the coke fuelled range was alight, water had been boiled and a hearty breakfast prepared to keep us insulated from the cold on our walk to school.
She was not a conventionally beautiful woman, but apple cheeks, dimples and an endearing smile, radiated warmth and internal loveliness. (The picture above shows my mother, Mary Baum, holding me as an overweight baby in December 1937)
From her forties onwards she was stout, but in those days even the most fashion conscious women relied on whale bone rather than “weightwatchers” to define their waist and redistribute the fat above and below the belt. She was always smartly “turned out” and would never be seen out of doors without makeup and a feather in her rakish hat. Most of all though she prided herself on her long black hair which she assured me came down to her waist. I could never confirm this as she was too proud to leave her bed room without her hair fixed up in a complex chignon secured in place like a Japanese Geisha girl. The loss of her hair and its replacement with a silk scarf, was the final insult that the cancer could hurl at her; and for what purpose?
One evening 20 years after my mother’s death, I received a phone call from my sister Linda, then aged 48. She explained that she had just noticed a lump in her right breast, her GP had referred her to the local surgeon who had reassured her but arranged for a biopsy in about two months time. By this time I was Professor of surgery at the Royal Marsden Hospital in London, the most prestigious specialist cancer centre in the UK. I swallowed hard and suggested that she got a second opinion from Mr. Nigel Sacks, a man I trusted because as my senior lecturer I had witnessed the care and skill of his practice first hand. It has to be understood that I couldn’t examine my own sister or trust my own judgment, in part out of decorum and in part out of emotional involvement. He saw her the next day and completed the “triple assessment”; that is clinical examination, X rays and a needle biopsy. Within the hour her cancer was diagnosed! Within the week she had surgery that consisted of a “lumpectomy” and partial excision of the lymph nodes in her right axilla. She was home in two days and happily the pathology was favorable. The margins of excision were clear of disease, the tumour was low grade and hormone receptor positive (see chapter 14) and finally the lymph nodes were declared free of malignant deposits. She was started on tamoxifen which she took without side effects for 5 years and underwent a 6 weeks course of radiotherapy to the breast. Without tempting providence I’m happy to say that 12 years later she is still alive and well and still my lovely sister Linda, who follows in my mother’s footsteps as an ayshet chayil. She has four vivacious daughters who I adore and I think they reciprocate my love. She also has a vivacious dog with which I share a relationship of mutual distaste.
Without wishing to over-dramatize the case, I feel that to some extent I’ve expunged a little of the guilt I felt over my failure to help my mother. I transferred my sister’s care to a top specialist and expedited her diagnosis and treatment. Most of all I have to take some satisfaction in having lead the team that first demonstrated that the drug, tamoxifen could reduce breast cancer mortality.
Two years ago Linda’s oldest daughter Anna, came to see me for advice. I’m sure she wouldn’t mind me describing her as theatrical in all senses of the word, but on this occasion I felt that her anxieties were legitimate. Her mother and grandmother had breast cancer and the circumstances of her great grandmother’s death also gave rise to concern. In addition we are of Ashkenasi extraction. All this hinted at the possibility of a germ line mutation in the BRCA gene pool which if present could lead to an 80% lifetime chance of developing breast cancer (see chapter xxx). I referred her on to my friend Ros Eeles, a leading cancer geneticist at the Royal Marsden Hospital, who agreed that the family pedigree did suggest a risk of carrying a breast cancer predisposition gene. With counseling and agreement from the whole family my sister was tested for the “Ashkenasi” mutations on BRCA 1 and BRCA 2. To everyone’s relief Linda was not found to be a carrier.
This story of three generations of my family neatly encapsulates the evolving story of progress in the fight against breast cancer over the forty years since I got involved in the campaign. My mother was too ignorant and or modest to be aware of the disease. Cancer the “big C” was not talked about or considered almost a stigma close to that associated with “a spot on the lung”, the euphemism for tuberculosis. Euphemisms for breast cancer were legion including chronic mastitis, neoplasia, mitotic lesions and at worst a tumour, that literally means a swelling. As a result of all this most cancers presented in a late stage either inoperable or with overt distant spread (metastases). Even if operable the surgery would be a mutilating Halsted radical mastectomy (see chapter 6).With no malice intended, women where considered too emotionally labile to handle the truth, so the diagnosis and treatment were discussed with the husband and sons. (I still encounter this cultural mind set with some of my private patients from Pakistan, Saudi Arabia and the Gulf states). Finally palliative care and symptom control were poorly developed and patients suffered unnecessarily. The myth that adequate opiate analgesia shortens life has now been exploded, in fact the opposite is true. Too little and too late has been replaced by adequate and in good time.
By the time my sister presented breast cancer the subject was no longer stigmatized and breast cancer awareness campaigns were making their mark. Diagnosis was available in a “one stop shop” within the hour, matching “Quikfit” car exhaust replacement for efficiency.
Surgery in most cases can now provide breast conservation with a decent cosmetic outcome without compromising the chance of cure and adjuvant systemic therapy can prolong life or even provide a cure. The development of clinical nurse specialists and the subject of psycho-oncolgy have enhanced quality of life and the developments in palliative care and the hospice movement have improved quality of dying.
The experience with my niece provides a pointer to the future. The genetic code for the rare familial predisposition to breast cancer has been cracked. The mechanism that explains why a faulty gene can lead to cancer is understood and opportunities for prevention are opening up . Within a few years I expect the genetic explanation for sporadic breast cancers will be understood and along with that smart was of preventing the disease will be discovered. In the immediate future we can expect more effective systemic therapy tailored to the individual cancer with specific molecular targets in its aim. Even as I write, tamoxifen the gold standard for thirty years is being replaced by a new class of compound (the aromatase inhibitors) that are not only more effective but carry fewer side effects.
How all this came about is a fascinating story that touches on the history of medicine, the philosophy of science and the introduction of the humanities into medical education.
This book is about my life, how it was shaped by the savage breast and my modest contribution to the subject. It is also my genuine wish that this story will humanize the subject, demystify breast cancer, help the afflicted and her family but most of all offer hope for the future.
One evening 20 years after my mother’s death, I received a phone call from my sister Linda, then aged 48. She explained that she had just noticed a lump in her right breast, her GP had referred her to the local surgeon who had reassured her but arranged for a biopsy in about two months time. By this time I was Professor of surgery at the Royal Marsden Hospital in London, the most prestigious specialist cancer centre in the UK. I swallowed hard and suggested that she got a second opinion from Mr. Nigel Sacks, a man I trusted because as my senior lecturer I had witnessed the care and skill of his practice first hand. It has to be understood that I couldn’t examine my own sister or trust my own judgment, in part out of decorum and in part out of emotional involvement. He saw her the next day and completed the “triple assessment”; that is clinical examination, X rays and a needle biopsy. Within the hour her cancer was diagnosed! Within the week she had surgery that consisted of a “lumpectomy” and partial excision of the lymph nodes in her right axilla. She was home in two days and happily the pathology was favorable. The margins of excision were clear of disease, the tumour was low grade and hormone receptor positive (see chapter 14) and finally the lymph nodes were declared free of malignant deposits. She was started on tamoxifen which she took without side effects for 5 years and underwent a 6 weeks course of radiotherapy to the breast. Without tempting providence I’m happy to say that 12 years later she is still alive and well and still my lovely sister Linda, who follows in my mother’s footsteps as an ayshet chayil. She has four vivacious daughters who I adore and I think they reciprocate my love. She also has a vivacious dog with which I share a relationship of mutual distaste.
Without wishing to over-dramatize the case, I feel that to some extent I’ve expunged a little of the guilt I felt over my failure to help my mother. I transferred my sister’s care to a top specialist and expedited her diagnosis and treatment. Most of all I have to take some satisfaction in having lead the team that first demonstrated that the drug, tamoxifen could reduce breast cancer mortality.
Two years ago Linda’s oldest daughter Anna, came to see me for advice. I’m sure she wouldn’t mind me describing her as theatrical in all senses of the word, but on this occasion I felt that her anxieties were legitimate. Her mother and grandmother had breast cancer and the circumstances of her great grandmother’s death also gave rise to concern. In addition we are of Ashkenasi extraction. All this hinted at the possibility of a germ line mutation in the BRCA gene pool which if present could lead to an 80% lifetime chance of developing breast cancer (see chapter xxx). I referred her on to my friend Ros Eeles, a leading cancer geneticist at the Royal Marsden Hospital, who agreed that the family pedigree did suggest a risk of carrying a breast cancer predisposition gene. With counseling and agreement from the whole family my sister was tested for the “Ashkenasi” mutations on BRCA 1 and BRCA 2. To everyone’s relief Linda was not found to be a carrier.
This story of three generations of my family neatly encapsulates the evolving story of progress in the fight against breast cancer over the forty years since I got involved in the campaign. My mother was too ignorant and or modest to be aware of the disease. Cancer the “big C” was not talked about or considered almost a stigma close to that associated with “a spot on the lung”, the euphemism for tuberculosis. Euphemisms for breast cancer were legion including chronic mastitis, neoplasia, mitotic lesions and at worst a tumour, that literally means a swelling. As a result of all this most cancers presented in a late stage either inoperable or with overt distant spread (metastases). Even if operable the surgery would be a mutilating Halsted radical mastectomy (see chapter 6).With no malice intended, women where considered too emotionally labile to handle the truth, so the diagnosis and treatment were discussed with the husband and sons. (I still encounter this cultural mind set with some of my private patients from Pakistan, Saudi Arabia and the Gulf states). Finally palliative care and symptom control were poorly developed and patients suffered unnecessarily. The myth that adequate opiate analgesia shortens life has now been exploded, in fact the opposite is true. Too little and too late has been replaced by adequate and in good time.
By the time my sister presented breast cancer the subject was no longer stigmatized and breast cancer awareness campaigns were making their mark. Diagnosis was available in a “one stop shop” within the hour, matching “Quikfit” car exhaust replacement for efficiency.
Surgery in most cases can now provide breast conservation with a decent cosmetic outcome without compromising the chance of cure and adjuvant systemic therapy can prolong life or even provide a cure. The development of clinical nurse specialists and the subject of psycho-oncolgy have enhanced quality of life and the developments in palliative care and the hospice movement have improved quality of dying.
The experience with my niece provides a pointer to the future. The genetic code for the rare familial predisposition to breast cancer has been cracked. The mechanism that explains why a faulty gene can lead to cancer is understood and opportunities for prevention are opening up . Within a few years I expect the genetic explanation for sporadic breast cancers will be understood and along with that smart was of preventing the disease will be discovered. In the immediate future we can expect more effective systemic therapy tailored to the individual cancer with specific molecular targets in its aim. Even as I write, tamoxifen the gold standard for thirty years is being replaced by a new class of compound (the aromatase inhibitors) that are not only more effective but carry fewer side effects.
How all this came about is a fascinating story that touches on the history of medicine, the philosophy of science and the introduction of the humanities into medical education.
This book is about my life, how it was shaped by the savage breast and my modest contribution to the subject. It is also my genuine wish that this story will humanize the subject, demystify breast cancer, help the afflicted and her family but most of all offer hope for the future.
**********************************
Chapter 3
The Simple Son
“Then the simple son, enquired
What should Passover mean to me?
To which his father replied
You were freed from slavery”
The Haggadah
I was born in the East End of London on May 31st 1937 at 12.00 noon, the day of the Grand National. My father often told the story of his little flutter on the race. He was torn between “Royal Mail” and “Midday Sun” and chose the latter partly because of his left wing tendency and partly because his third son was born at midday. Royal Mail came in at 100/6 whilst Midday Sun broke a leg and had to be shot. I was not amused by this story and felt it as a bad omen, starting life with an inferiority complex. This was not helped by the fact that I was the third of four sons. On the eves of the first and second days of Passover all Jews celebrate the Seder night, where we read out the story of the exodus from Egypt. The master of the house conducts the service from a beautifully illustrated book, the Haggadah. As well as the narrative, the service is interspersed with the eating of foods rich in symbolism, nursery songs to keep the youngsters awake, ritual debates and homilies. Amongst the latter is the tale of the four sons. One is wise, the second wicked, the third simple and the fourth too young to understand. Each is given the task of questioning the leader of the service on the meaning of the festivities. In the tradition of our family each son had to act the part according to seniority. My eldest brother Geoffrey was the wise son, my brother Harold the wicked, me the simple and the youngest David as the “child who does not know how to ask”. My lines were easy to learn all I had to say was “what is all this then?” What started as simple play-acting fed a growing understanding that I was indeed the simple one in the family as well as the one doomed to fall at the first fence. Surprisingly, I never resented this role, which soon became a self -fulfilling prophecy, and took great consolation from the achievements of my siblings. It was only when I became a senior academic did I begin to appreciate the importance of the naive question, “what is all this then?” and how do we know?
Before I tell you about my family and upbringing I want to try a give a flavor of life in England in the mid to late 1930s. To do this I’ve drawn on my earliest memories, family folklore and from a series of Punch magazines of 1937 that I bought in a car boot sale. England in the late 1930s was at a transition between Edwardian values and Modernism. This was well illustrated by the graphic art In Punch at this time. At one extreme we see the classicism of Bernard Partridge whilst at the other the extreme simplicity of line by Fougasse. It is also immediately apparent that every household had servants who are illustrated in cartoons of either self-satire or what would now be considered most politically incorrect, mockery of the servant class. The first might include that famous series by Pont, lampooning the British Character. In one captioned “Love of never throwing anything away”, we see a uniformed maid looking in despair at the clutter in the attic. In another captioned “Absence of ideas for meals” it is the mistress of the house who holds her head in despair whilst cook waits impassively. As far as the second category is concerned this exchange appears below a meticulous drawing of madam addressing the maid. “Mary, your mother has just telephoned to say your sister has flu”. “Flew, Madam? But where has she went?” Funny thing is, although I grew up in a family that appeared to be penniless, we always had a maid. The maid was always from Ireland as I recall and mother had to be “let one go” because she had a crush on my brother Geoff. In Punch of that time middle class men sported bristly moustaches, wore hats and spats and smoked Craven “A”, made specially “to prevent sore throats”. My father could have been the stereotype for the protagonists in this one. “Hallo, old man, I thought you were on a diet “. “Ah, I had my diet at home before I came to the club”. Yet behind this veneer of jolly old England, Punch was sensitive to the early signs of the gathering storm. In one cartoon that I still find funny, we see the House of Commons with all the members wearing gas masks. (“Gas drill at Westminster”) One MP is on his feet addressing the house declaiming, “And I think I may confidently say, judging from the expressions on the faces of the honourable members, that the house is in unanimous agreement with the views I have expressed” Clearly then as now the public were afraid of enemies who might attack with chemical and biological weapons. Another more somber in tone reminds us of the anti-war faction in the UK before Hitler invaded Poland. We see Sir Stafford Cripps standing on a soap- box ranting away whilst in the background we see darkening clouds and a sky full of bombers labeled “Foreign Menace”
The caption reads, “Today you have the most glorious opportunity that the workers have ever had...refuse to make munitions, refuse to make armaments.” In fact my first, albeit fragmented memories, are of the blitz round about 1941/42 when I must have been about four or five. I remember the sirens followed by the night -time rush to the Anderson shelter that my father and helpers had dug in the garden. I wasn’t frightened but because of the competition to get on the top bunk I rushed out ahead of the family and slipped down the rain slicked step of our bunker. I remember the steel re-enforced kitchen table that served as a shelter if the alarm hadn’t sounded before the first bomb fell. My two older brothers would scoop up their books or schoolwork and carry on reading under the table barely missing a beat. Because of the blitz my father moved the family from the East End of London to Birmingham and when the bombers followed us there, to Halesowen in the Black Country. There I remember being held up at a window to see Coventry in flames as the Germans bombed it to Hell. There was no hiding the little ones in the industrial cities any more so for a short time we became evacuees in a Welsh-farming community. I must have been very unhappy there because ever since I’ve had an aversion to the country although I love the Welsh.
At the end of the war when I was 7 or 8 my father moved us back to Birmingham from when my coherent memories begin. We lived in a large rambling Edwardian House at the corner of Sandon Road and City Road in Edgbaston. No long afterwards the first premonition of a new addition to the family occurred when a starling flew into the scullery where my mother was washing up. Summoned by her screams I was to learn, that according to family legend, each Baum pregnancy, was signaled by a bird flying into the house. Furthermore all Baum children are born with a bird shaped birth- marks on their back. Indeed I have a birth mark on my back that could just about be interpreted as a bird with folded wings but the symbolism of all this escaped me and only added to my sense of insecurity suggesting once again that my fate was pre-determined. Six months later, with much rejoicing, my baby sister Linda was born. My mother was about 40 at that time but she and my father were desperate to have a daughter (Girls are a rare commodity in my family and of my 8 grandchildren only one is of the female gender)
As already mentioned my father was a very handsome and dapper gentleman who served in Dad’s Army (The Home Guard) during the war with great distinction; putting out incendiary bombs with a stirrup pump and going on maneuvers with live ammunition to my mother’s alarm. Fortunately the West Midlands never saw German parachutists and the nearest he came to the enemy was when a Mescherschmit crash landed in a neighboring field with Gerry in the cockpit. My Dad’s daytime job was as a special agent. Until I was brutally enlightened I always thought that he was a spy like “Dick Barton-Special Agent” the hero of a popular radio serial drama. Sadly his work was neither glamorous nor rewarding. He wasn’t an agent of the state but an agent of the schmutter business, schmutter being Yiddish for rags. In other words he sold women’s dresses to the high street retailers. I learnt of his daily humiliations the hard way when eventually joining him as a helper on his daily rounds during the long summer holidays. I remember how he was patronized or kept waiting by the “all-important” buyers for the lady’s gown departments of the local Black Country towns. Here was a man with no formal education beyond the age of 11 with parents who only spoke Yiddish and sadly no flare for or patience with the world of commerce. Condemned to a lifetime struggle to finance a large and hungry family he yet managed to educate himself through his voracious appetite for books. He was clearly a very intelligent man, representing the City of Birmingham at bridge and chess. He could play 12 boards simultaneously and win them all blindfolded. Apart from these activities he fought hard for some kind of self-esteem via the Masonic Lodge and the Hebrew Community. He went on to become Worshipful Master of his Lodge and represented the Birmingham Jewish Community on the Board of Deputies of British Jewry. Sadly this lead to many rows between my parents as his business suffered through neglect. In the end like many of his generation he looked towards his children to benefit from the advantages of living in a free, liberal and democratic nation that of course included a free and liberal education. In the meantime, unrecognized until many years later, the central component of my education was already fixed in place by the ubiquity of books cluttering the house and the passionate dialectic of the family debates around the Friday night dinner table. It must have been here that I learnt to see the “other hand” of the “on the one hand but other the other hand” duality. It must have been here that I learnt to enjoy defending the indefensible just for the hell of it. Apart from the ritual of the Erev Shabbat I enjoyed a reasonably strict orthodox Jewish upbringing. This meant walking about three miles to the Birmingham Singer’s Hill Synagogue every Saturday morning and sitting through endless sermons. It also meant attending all the Festivals most of which congregated round the beginning of each new school term which didn’t help my secular education. At the age of 13 I was Bar Mitzvahed. By all accounts I had a beautiful singing voice before puberty and I had the congregation in tears with my readings from the Torah Scroll and the Prophets. The most memorable event on that day was the cheque I received from my rich, flamboyant and philandering uncle Sid. It was made out for £13.12s.6p, a princely if somewhat mysterious sum for those days. Later it emerged that he got his cheques mixed up and this one should have gone to his turf accountant. Instead I got a large white 5 quid note the size of a hankerchief, which somehow felt more valuable than the cheque, not that it mattered as my Father pocketed all the money gifts to pay for the function, but I got to keep the fountain pens. I never found out what a turf accountant was but from the hushed tones of my parents I suspected it was something dirty. From the age of 13 I was meant to fulfill all the religious duties of an adult Jew and every so often my paternal grandfather would descend on the household, with the vengeance and appearance of an Old Testament prophet, to check up on the minutiae of my observance. Things got a little better when suddenly, at the age of 13 ½, I noticed that there were girls sitting in the upstairs gallery. I then realized that as we had a mixed choir and I had a good voice that religious observance wouldn’t be too tiresome if I joined the choir.
My oldest brother Geoff, was the first in the family to go to University, he qualified in Medicine in 1955 and started off as a gallant captain in the RAMC in Egypt before settling into a successful career as a general practitioner. He was also a first class rugby player, a member of Moseley RFC and a county trialist. I always idolized him and for many years he served as my role model. Next in seniority was my brother Harold. He was extremely gifted academically and was something of a prodigy at school. He went on to become Professor of biochemistry and Dean of life science at Kings College London. It was through him that I discovered the meaning of the scientific process and the thirst for discovery. He is still a great lyricist and famous for composing the Biochemist’s song book. My youngest brother David “crept up from behind” to win every prize, including the rarely minted gold medal, on qualifying in medicine at Birmingham University three years after me in 1963. He enjoyed a spectacular career rising to become Professor of Paediatrics and Child Health at Bristol University and then President of his Royal College. He died at the age of 59 literally whilst in the saddle, leading a charity bike ride to raise money to support the health care needs of the children victims of the Balkan wars. He taught me the meaning of hard work, vision and self- belief. The youngest of us all was our beloved little sister who went on to serve the NHS as a hard working underpaid speech therapist. When she followed my mother with a diagnosis of breast cancer at the age of 45 my world turned over and my mission shifted from career development for its own sake to one fueled by a fire in my belly to rid the world of breast cancer. What sheer bloody arrogance and conceit you might think and rightly so, yet my youngest brother set out to change the world of childhood suffering and died in the attempt. He always illustrated his attitude with the parable of the star-fish.
An old man walking on the beach at dawn noticed a boy picking up a starfish and throwing it into the sea. When asked why, the boy explained that the stranded starfish would die if left to lie in the morning sun. 'But there are millions of starfish on this beach,' said the old man. 'How can your efforts make a difference?' The boy picked up another starfish and placed it in the waves. 'It makes a difference to this one,' he said.
Little guys like us can change the world a little for the better if we all have high ambitions and are willing to fail triumphantly.
However it was a long and rocky road to develop that self- belief and shake off my childish notion of being the stupid son. The nadir of my academic achievements was when I became bottom of the class in a third rate grammar school in Birmingham. My father feigned delight and explained that I would be looked after if I left school at 16 and joined him in business. The thought of this living hell, as experienced whilst helping out in my summer holidays, galvanized me into action. I gained reasonable results at GCSE O levels and then surprised my family and myself by gaining a State Scholarship that allowed me to follow my brothers into Birmingham University in 1955.
As much as I hated grammar school, I loved medical school. I loved the camaraderie around the cadaver on the anatomy dissecting table, I loved the patient contact on the medical firms, I loved the drama of A&E and the operating theatre but most of all I loved the rugger/bugger beer swilling parties and the goyisher girls at the Saturday night hops. Up until that time I’d never really drunk anything other than the sacramental kiddush wine on Friday night and Passover. Furthermore my relationship with the girls of the Jewish youth societies and study groups was decorous, inhibited by an intense shyness and consummated only by a fierce game of table tennis. Even the chance mention of a girls name at the family Friday night dinner was enough to make me blush to the roots of my hair and leave the table in confusion. Ahh!, but medical school and my two years “on the house” as a resident medical officer where heaven (as long as my parents didn’t find out!). I qualified as a doctor in 1960 with relative ease, enjoyed my appointment as house surgeon at my teaching hospital, the Queen Elizabeth Hospital Birmingham and experienced the excitement and instant gratification as a senior house officer in A & E at the Birmingham General Hospital. I passed my primary FRCS (Fellow of the Royal College of Surgeons) studying in my spare time and was all set for a career in surgery when I was overtaken by Zionistic zeal. In the Spring of 1963 I approached the Jewish agency in Tel Aviv and in no time at all was on the SS Theodore Herzl, out of Marseilles en route to Haifa.
*********************************************************
Chapter 4
Israel 1963-1964
I am British by accident of birth thanks to the fact that both my sets of grandparents escaped the pogroms in Russia and Poland, by fleeing to London early in the last century. This country has been good to our family, providing us with free health care and a free education that allowed my three brothers and I to reach the highest levels of academia. My youngest brother David ended his life as President of the Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health (RCPCH) and is buried in Rosh Pinah overlooking the Sea of Galilee in Northern Israel. His will and his family’s choice of this burial site reflect the spiritual pull of Israel for many Western Jews. His last act was to establish a children’s clinic in Gaza for the training of Palestinian doctors. This project amongst others is continued by the RCPCH in the name of the David Baum International Fund (DBIF). This act also reflects the Jewish angst about the suffering of the Palestinians.
In May 2004 I was a guest of the University in Haifa, along with a small faculty from the USA, for a workshop on the prevention of cancer. Cancer epidemiology is one of the strengths in Israeli medical research. The Israeli population is an extraordinary mix of ethnic types who retain the majority of their genetic and cultural distinctions. This provides an almost unique “natural experiment” for the study of the contributions of both nature and nurture to the risk of developing breast cancer. On the one hand we have the Ashkenazi and Sephardi Jews with similar cultures but striking difference is their risk of inheritance of mutations for the breast cancer predisposition (BRCA) genes. On the other hand we have the village and nomadic Arab (Bedouin) populations with similar genetic pools but very different life styles. There are also the Christian Arabs, Bahai and Druze. As well as their different risk factors their different cultures and life styles provide unique problems for screening and management of the disease. Israeli academics have exploited these opportunities in a way that informs the rest of the world.
Haifa is a beautiful city dominated by the Bahai temple and gardens occupying the slopes of Mount Carmel. l warmly approve of the Bahai belief system because of its tolerance and universal appeal. The Bahai’s elected to set up their HQ in Haifa because, as a breakaway sect of Islam, they were persecuted in all Islamic countries. For hundreds of years the Arab and Jewish population have got on well in Haifa, with many joint projects and an Arab Mayor quite recently. This peaceful co-existence was shattered by the second intifada.
From Haifa we were driven down the axis of the country just to the West of the new barrier that separates the disputed territories, from Israel proper. 95% of its length it is a wire fence with electronic surveillance devises, the remainder is made up of ugly concrete walls that are shown on TV. No one mentions that this is to stop the snipers firing on traffic on the A6 motorway from high-rise apartments that abut the road. I have little doubt that some sections of the wall have caused hardship and a recent appeal by Palestinians to the Israeli high court was successful and sections of the wall will be re-routed. If there were any Jews left in Arab lands I can’t imagine the reverse holding true, but then they were all expelled after the 1948 war, a silent 800,000 that the world press never acknowledges. The fence works and the terrorist atrocities in Northern Israel have been stifled.
Having reached Beer-Sheba we turned east to the Dead Sea. Along the way we saw many new villages housing the Bedouin tribes. Their romantic nomadic life was in fact brutal and short and although they maintain all their traditions of hospitality in their black tents, their health and quality of life has been improved by settling them on pasture- land with free schooling and health care. The Bedu are loyal Israeli citizens and even serve in the Israel Defence Force (IDF).
The ride down to the Dead Sea never fails to strike awe in my heart but the effect is then spoiled when you arrive at the luxury hotels at Ein Bokkek close to the biblical site of Sodom. Here the visiting faculty spoke to a conference of about 200 Israeli and Arab doctors. My role was to discuss the pros and cons of screening for breast and prostate cancer. After the meeting a group of us travelled 20 Km North to Massada, the famous archaeological site that marks Herod’s winter Palace and the last stand of the Jewish resistance to the Roman occupation after the destruction of the second Temple in 70CE. On this barren plateau 1,000 meters above the Dead Sea the view looking east to the mountains of Moab is breathtaking. You can still see the Roman siege wall and pray in the oldest synagogue in the world. You may know the story of how after a three year siege, the 900 survivors committed suicide rather than surrender to the Romans who persecuted them because of their faith. For this reason Massada has become a symbol of resistance in Israel and the graduation ceremony for certain brigades of the IDF takes place on Massada, where they pledge, “Shaynit M’zada Lo Tipol”, Massada will not fall a second time. I find this kind of heroic militarism embarrassing, after all I never let my kids and grandchildren play with guns and toy tanks, but we enjoy security apart from the odd threat of an IRA or an Al Qu’aida bomb. In Israel though, this pledge to self-defence is not paranoia, because for more than 50 years the combined armies of Syria, Jordan, Iraq, Iran and Egypt have had various goes at taking Massada a second time. Fortunately Egypt and Jordan have negotiated peace whilst Iraq has other problems on its mind at the moment.
At the base of the mountain is a beautiful new museum that describes the archaeological history of the area and the history of its excavation. In the latter section I was startled and almost moved to tears to see a picture of myself aged 27, resplendent in a chequered keffiya and a red beard from the time I was acting as deputy medical officer on the dig during the winter season 1963/64.
Shortly after gaining my primary FRCS whilst working in the A & E department of the Birmingham General Hospital, I went to work in Israel. I was motivated by a lust for adventure, a need for surgical experience in the field and as a visionary Zionist. According to the new left wing ideology, Zionism is a dirty word stigmatised by the infamous UN resolution that equated Zionism with Racism in 1971. In truth the Zionist movement is merely an expression of the Jewish people’s yearning to find security in a land they can call their own after two millennia of persecution. Even amongst my own friends and family who have grown up in this country and never experienced a whiff of anti-Semitism, I detect paranoia in our dinner party conversations. Mostly this is due to a vestigial folk sub-consciousness but more recently this has been fuelled by the unholy alliance of the extreme left wing media and the fundamentalist amongst our Islamic population.
There are secular and religious Zionists who may be right wing or left wing. I would classify myself as of the left leaning secular variety. The accusation that Zionism is an expression of racism and apartheid can be refuted simply by noting the treatment of the Bedu described above and my first hand experience described below.
In the spring of 1963 I packed all my worldly belongings in one suitcase closed my bank account, taking the balance of £70.00 as my only asset and made my way down south to Marseilles. There I boarded the Theodore Herzl and for three days sailed East to the Promised Land. As Mount Carmel and Haifa emerged out of the early morning haze there wasn’t a dry eye amongst those making aliyah (literally translated as assent but meaning immigration) that crowded the bow deck. From Haifa I made my way to Tel-Aviv and the offices of the Jewish Agency with whom I had been conducting my affairs and from whom I had been promised a job as a junior surgeon in the newly opened teaching hospital in Beer-Sheba. That was where my troubles began. This utterly incompetent and bureaucratic organization had no knowledge of my existence, the job did not exist and the hospital was still on the drawing board. I found temporary accommodation in a hostel for English speaking immigrants, Bet Brodedsky in Ramat Aviv, just North of Tel Aviv, and set out to find work. I blew most of my savings on a second hand Vespa and wasted a week queuing in the dusty heat at a series of departments that controlled traffic regulations, to get my driving licence. Thus my first disillusionments with the Zionist dream were my first encounters with the infamous bureaurocracy of this new democratic nation.
That aside I was elated by the sense of devil may care freedom from all responsibilities, the wind in my hair in the heat of a beautiful Israeli Spring and the thrill of my first assent to the Golden city of Jerusalem. The elation didn’t last long as first I was hit full in the face by the chumsin, the hot dry wind that blows off the Arabian peninsula sporadically at that time of year and is known to drive people into a homicidal frenzy, and secondly by the problem of finding a job. Naively I had assumed that the world was waiting for me; this brilliant young English surgeon with half a FRCS under his belt. In reality I found out that there was an overabundance of doctors in Israel, the heads of departments were mostly German refugees who didn’t rate the FRCS and finally my rudimentary command of Ivrit, (modern Hebrew), was considered a disadvantage. Even if I spoke English very slowly and loudly it didn’t help my case! Like most Jewish boys I learnt biblical Hebrew at cheder, (Sunday school). I could read from the prayer books and sight -read the melodies from the encrypted notation in the Chumash, the books of the Torah and Prophets. This was only of limited value for me for the following reasons: the pronunciation was different, the writing of Modern Hebrew lacks vowels and there were no words for cholecystectomy or achlorhydria. I was as much use in the surgical out patient department in Israel as someone whose English began an ended with Beowulf would be in the NHS A&E department. Eventually I became quite fluent in ivrit from a combination of evening classes and learning on the job. Although to begin with my chat up line on first (and usually last) dates with Israeli nurses was limited to polite enquiry as to the regularity of their bowel and menstrual function. With even greater experience and fluency I ventured into the territory of urinary frequency and abdominal cramps. I also was in deep trouble in the operating theatre because the words for scissors, trousers and spectacles sounded almost alike to my untrained ear. Imagine asking for a sharp pair of trousers when trying to cut through dense fibrous tissue in a case of diverticulitis! Joking aside this experience taught me what it must be like to be a new immigrant in the UK from the Indian subcontinent who suffer humiliations and ridicule because of their failure to master the English language. This must have been how my Yiddish speaking grandparents felt 100 years ago.
Eventually I was posted to a large community hospital in Afula serving the Jezreal valley and caring for the needs of a mixed bunch of secular Jewish Kibbutzniks, Religious Jews from S’fad, Moslem Arabs from the local villages and Christian Arabs from Nazareth; an exotic brew of folk who were all treated with equal respect or occasionally equal rudeness! Many of the doctors were Arabs trained in Israel and there was some intermarriage on the campus.
In spite of my early difficulties I learnt much of lifelong value in the subjects of surgical techniques and human relationships. My mentor and head of department was Professor Shmuel Nissan recently in post after having been chief resident in an American teaching hospital. He was a tall, handsome and rugged character, who had been born into and old established Jewish Palestinian family, veterans of the first aliyah. A multi-cultured man, he was fluent in Arabic as well as English and Ivrit and was popular amongst the elders of some of the local Arab villages. He grew citrus fruit on his farm and raised Arab horses and was also a medical historian. He ultimately went on to become chief of surgery at the Mount Scopus branch of the Hadassah hospital in Jerusalem. He taught me how to do a real radical mastectomy the American Halsted technique [ see chapter xxx].
Apart from learning the skills of elective surgery I had my share of emergency work. Being essentially a rural community I remember a number of grizzly accidents with tractors. More important than this was my modest yet informative introduction into the management of gunshot wounds. Although 1963-65 was a relatively peaceful time in the history of Israel there were still feddayin raids and sniper fire from the Golan hights, aimed at farmers in the fertile Beit Shan valley below. There was one extraordinary incident when I had to deal with two soldiers shot with one bullet as they patrolled the border. The sniper had managed to pierce the hand of the nearest and the shoulder of the second as they rode together in a comradely pose. On that occasion I had to give evidence to the blue berets of the UN soldiers monitoring the peace. There were hundreds of such incidents each year.
My next adventure was being sent to help out the Scottish Mission Hospital in Nazareth when their only surgeon was on sick leave. I loved the nuns who made up the nursing staff and admired their strict discipline that was in stark contrast to the laissez faire democratic attitude of the Israeli nurses in the kupat cholim (workers fund) hospital in Afula. The nuns acted as interpreters in the clinics and as surgical assistants in the theatre. By this time I was fairly proficient in the standard elective and emergencies but there was one occasion I operated with a book held up in front of me. One night a baby was born with an open spina bifida, a congenital defect where the spinal column fails to fuse over the spinal cord. With the spinal cord exposed, infection and meningitis would be inevitable and the nearest hospital with a paediatric surgeon was two hours away. Learning on the job I completed the task of mobilizing the delicate membranes around the spinal canal and succeeded in closing the defect. The baby survived but for all I knew went on to develop other complications linked to this congenital abnormality. From my current standpoint I shudder to think of my hubris at the time but I felt good about myself then and a pretty young nun made me hot chocolate before I collapsed exhausted into my bed which I sometimes shared with a pair of friendly gekkoes.
That aside my biggest adventure was being sent as deputy medical officer to the Masada dig.
Shmuel Nissan was the nephew of the President of the State of Israel, Zalman Shazan. He in turn was a close friend of Professor Yigal Yadin who was chief of staff of the IDF during the 1948 war of independence and as a second career went on to become Professor of archaeology at the Hebrew University in Jerusalem. He was in charge of the excavations of King Herod’s palace at Masada. Thus through a complex series of interactions, known in Israel as protectia I was invited to volunteer as deputy medical officer at the dig. One early morning in February 1963, I started my great adventure by bouncing along un-surfaced tracks in a military jeep driving due East from the desert town of Arad to the foot of the mountain plateau dominating the Western shore of the Dead Sea mid way between the salt works at S’dom (remember Lot’s wife?) and the oasis of Ein Gedi where King David hid in a cave from a vengeful King Saul. The archaeologist’s encampment was arranged just North of the remains of the Roman camp where Flavius Silva commanded the Roman legions in their three-year siege of the mountain fortress between 70 and 73 CE. The foot of the Roman siege ramp that rose nearly 1,000 feet to the summit separated the modern from the ancient invaders. In 73 CE the Roman foot soldiers and their siege machines stormed the fortifications at the top only to find that the 900 Jewish Zealots who had held out there following the sacking of Jerusalem and the destruction of the second temple, had committed suicide rather than fall into the hands of their enemies. As an archaeological site it was therefore of extraordinary value in providing insight into two periods of history, King Herod the Roman Viceroy and the period after the fall of the second temple.
I was housed in an army tent with three other volunteers and shared duties with a mysterious American doctor in his fifties, in a field hospital tent. Each morning before dawn we mounted to the summit up the Roman ramp and gazed in awe as the sun rose over the mountains Moab in Jordan across the early mist rising from the Dead Sea, then glancing down a 1,000 foot vertical drop to the salt plains below. Fortunately my medical skills were seldom called upon and I spent most of the time in charge of a small team digging out the debris of nearly two millennia from between the casement walls erected by King Herod to guard his Eastern flank. Our interest was in discovering the domestic details of the life of the zealots who set up home in these quarters. Two of the team dug and filled the buckets, I emptied the buckets into a large sieve held and shaken by another two volunteers. As they sieved the rubble and sand I looked for artefacts before the remaining debris was tipped over the edge of the cliff face. This way we found roman pottery shards and glassware shimmering with a fluorescent light in the strong sunshine, miraculously surviving from the time of Christ. Once we had cleared the bulk of the debris we began the careful task of cleaning the floor and searching for the clues of day -to -day life. I personally uncovered a cooking hearth by following down a trail of soot staining the junction of two stone walls. Hidden under a flag-stone making up the hearth I uncovered a rotting woven sack containing a congealed mass of bright blue discs. I watched with fascination as one of the professional archaeologists in the camp treated the find with dilute acetic acid following which the long hidden copper coinage revealed itself as new. The faces of the coins showed the chalice and the pomegranates marking them out as 73CE. So I found myself handling the loose change of a Jewish mother who had perished 1900 years earlier. The hairs stood up on the nape of my neck and one of the coins “stuck to the palm of my hand” serving as a lucky charm when I sat my exams to become a fellow of the Royal College of Surgeons in 1965.
The other moving experience for me was the celebration of the Jewish New Year for trees. Here we planted palm and myrtle in this long barren place that had once supported 900 souls for over three years and here we prayed in the first synagogue to be built after the destruction of the second temple.
For recreation we would climb down the precipitous snake path that wound down the Eastern escarpment and go off on rambles to explore the region of Ein Geddi or follow the encircling siege walls built by the Romans and still visible to all.
In the evening we would have lectures from the archaeologists including a memorable one by Professor Yadin himself, describing the finding of the Bar- Kochba caves just South of Qumran. Other evenings I would gather with my senior colleague and two lady friends for Turkish coffee and gossip in the field hospital. I could deduce nothing about the training or provenance of this American doctor but as we packed up to leave a month later he gave me an address just outside Florence suggesting we met up on my return to England.
A year later I found myself in Italy having landed at the Port of Rome en route home. A minor detour to Florence, lead me to the gate in the high wall protecting Villa Marcellio Fincino in Fiesoli. I later learnt that Fincino was one of the leading lights of the Italian renaissance. I was surprised to be shown into sumptuous gardens by a liveried servant who conducted me to his master sitting on the terrace of the most beautiful 16thC palace you can imagine. My host, the mysterious American doctor, owned a chain of private hospitals in the USA and according to his story was in hiding from hit men hired by his estranged wife. After a few days of luxury, living the life of a Florentine prince, I returned to England to pick up my career again and search for a wife.
Israel 1963-1964
I am British by accident of birth thanks to the fact that both my sets of grandparents escaped the pogroms in Russia and Poland, by fleeing to London early in the last century. This country has been good to our family, providing us with free health care and a free education that allowed my three brothers and I to reach the highest levels of academia. My youngest brother David ended his life as President of the Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health (RCPCH) and is buried in Rosh Pinah overlooking the Sea of Galilee in Northern Israel. His will and his family’s choice of this burial site reflect the spiritual pull of Israel for many Western Jews. His last act was to establish a children’s clinic in Gaza for the training of Palestinian doctors. This project amongst others is continued by the RCPCH in the name of the David Baum International Fund (DBIF). This act also reflects the Jewish angst about the suffering of the Palestinians.
In May 2004 I was a guest of the University in Haifa, along with a small faculty from the USA, for a workshop on the prevention of cancer. Cancer epidemiology is one of the strengths in Israeli medical research. The Israeli population is an extraordinary mix of ethnic types who retain the majority of their genetic and cultural distinctions. This provides an almost unique “natural experiment” for the study of the contributions of both nature and nurture to the risk of developing breast cancer. On the one hand we have the Ashkenazi and Sephardi Jews with similar cultures but striking difference is their risk of inheritance of mutations for the breast cancer predisposition (BRCA) genes. On the other hand we have the village and nomadic Arab (Bedouin) populations with similar genetic pools but very different life styles. There are also the Christian Arabs, Bahai and Druze. As well as their different risk factors their different cultures and life styles provide unique problems for screening and management of the disease. Israeli academics have exploited these opportunities in a way that informs the rest of the world.
Haifa is a beautiful city dominated by the Bahai temple and gardens occupying the slopes of Mount Carmel. l warmly approve of the Bahai belief system because of its tolerance and universal appeal. The Bahai’s elected to set up their HQ in Haifa because, as a breakaway sect of Islam, they were persecuted in all Islamic countries. For hundreds of years the Arab and Jewish population have got on well in Haifa, with many joint projects and an Arab Mayor quite recently. This peaceful co-existence was shattered by the second intifada.
From Haifa we were driven down the axis of the country just to the West of the new barrier that separates the disputed territories, from Israel proper. 95% of its length it is a wire fence with electronic surveillance devises, the remainder is made up of ugly concrete walls that are shown on TV. No one mentions that this is to stop the snipers firing on traffic on the A6 motorway from high-rise apartments that abut the road. I have little doubt that some sections of the wall have caused hardship and a recent appeal by Palestinians to the Israeli high court was successful and sections of the wall will be re-routed. If there were any Jews left in Arab lands I can’t imagine the reverse holding true, but then they were all expelled after the 1948 war, a silent 800,000 that the world press never acknowledges. The fence works and the terrorist atrocities in Northern Israel have been stifled.
Having reached Beer-Sheba we turned east to the Dead Sea. Along the way we saw many new villages housing the Bedouin tribes. Their romantic nomadic life was in fact brutal and short and although they maintain all their traditions of hospitality in their black tents, their health and quality of life has been improved by settling them on pasture- land with free schooling and health care. The Bedu are loyal Israeli citizens and even serve in the Israel Defence Force (IDF).
The ride down to the Dead Sea never fails to strike awe in my heart but the effect is then spoiled when you arrive at the luxury hotels at Ein Bokkek close to the biblical site of Sodom. Here the visiting faculty spoke to a conference of about 200 Israeli and Arab doctors. My role was to discuss the pros and cons of screening for breast and prostate cancer. After the meeting a group of us travelled 20 Km North to Massada, the famous archaeological site that marks Herod’s winter Palace and the last stand of the Jewish resistance to the Roman occupation after the destruction of the second Temple in 70CE. On this barren plateau 1,000 meters above the Dead Sea the view looking east to the mountains of Moab is breathtaking. You can still see the Roman siege wall and pray in the oldest synagogue in the world. You may know the story of how after a three year siege, the 900 survivors committed suicide rather than surrender to the Romans who persecuted them because of their faith. For this reason Massada has become a symbol of resistance in Israel and the graduation ceremony for certain brigades of the IDF takes place on Massada, where they pledge, “Shaynit M’zada Lo Tipol”, Massada will not fall a second time. I find this kind of heroic militarism embarrassing, after all I never let my kids and grandchildren play with guns and toy tanks, but we enjoy security apart from the odd threat of an IRA or an Al Qu’aida bomb. In Israel though, this pledge to self-defence is not paranoia, because for more than 50 years the combined armies of Syria, Jordan, Iraq, Iran and Egypt have had various goes at taking Massada a second time. Fortunately Egypt and Jordan have negotiated peace whilst Iraq has other problems on its mind at the moment.
At the base of the mountain is a beautiful new museum that describes the archaeological history of the area and the history of its excavation. In the latter section I was startled and almost moved to tears to see a picture of myself aged 27, resplendent in a chequered keffiya and a red beard from the time I was acting as deputy medical officer on the dig during the winter season 1963/64.
Shortly after gaining my primary FRCS whilst working in the A & E department of the Birmingham General Hospital, I went to work in Israel. I was motivated by a lust for adventure, a need for surgical experience in the field and as a visionary Zionist. According to the new left wing ideology, Zionism is a dirty word stigmatised by the infamous UN resolution that equated Zionism with Racism in 1971. In truth the Zionist movement is merely an expression of the Jewish people’s yearning to find security in a land they can call their own after two millennia of persecution. Even amongst my own friends and family who have grown up in this country and never experienced a whiff of anti-Semitism, I detect paranoia in our dinner party conversations. Mostly this is due to a vestigial folk sub-consciousness but more recently this has been fuelled by the unholy alliance of the extreme left wing media and the fundamentalist amongst our Islamic population.
There are secular and religious Zionists who may be right wing or left wing. I would classify myself as of the left leaning secular variety. The accusation that Zionism is an expression of racism and apartheid can be refuted simply by noting the treatment of the Bedu described above and my first hand experience described below.
In the spring of 1963 I packed all my worldly belongings in one suitcase closed my bank account, taking the balance of £70.00 as my only asset and made my way down south to Marseilles. There I boarded the Theodore Herzl and for three days sailed East to the Promised Land. As Mount Carmel and Haifa emerged out of the early morning haze there wasn’t a dry eye amongst those making aliyah (literally translated as assent but meaning immigration) that crowded the bow deck. From Haifa I made my way to Tel-Aviv and the offices of the Jewish Agency with whom I had been conducting my affairs and from whom I had been promised a job as a junior surgeon in the newly opened teaching hospital in Beer-Sheba. That was where my troubles began. This utterly incompetent and bureaucratic organization had no knowledge of my existence, the job did not exist and the hospital was still on the drawing board. I found temporary accommodation in a hostel for English speaking immigrants, Bet Brodedsky in Ramat Aviv, just North of Tel Aviv, and set out to find work. I blew most of my savings on a second hand Vespa and wasted a week queuing in the dusty heat at a series of departments that controlled traffic regulations, to get my driving licence. Thus my first disillusionments with the Zionist dream were my first encounters with the infamous bureaurocracy of this new democratic nation.
That aside I was elated by the sense of devil may care freedom from all responsibilities, the wind in my hair in the heat of a beautiful Israeli Spring and the thrill of my first assent to the Golden city of Jerusalem. The elation didn’t last long as first I was hit full in the face by the chumsin, the hot dry wind that blows off the Arabian peninsula sporadically at that time of year and is known to drive people into a homicidal frenzy, and secondly by the problem of finding a job. Naively I had assumed that the world was waiting for me; this brilliant young English surgeon with half a FRCS under his belt. In reality I found out that there was an overabundance of doctors in Israel, the heads of departments were mostly German refugees who didn’t rate the FRCS and finally my rudimentary command of Ivrit, (modern Hebrew), was considered a disadvantage. Even if I spoke English very slowly and loudly it didn’t help my case! Like most Jewish boys I learnt biblical Hebrew at cheder, (Sunday school). I could read from the prayer books and sight -read the melodies from the encrypted notation in the Chumash, the books of the Torah and Prophets. This was only of limited value for me for the following reasons: the pronunciation was different, the writing of Modern Hebrew lacks vowels and there were no words for cholecystectomy or achlorhydria. I was as much use in the surgical out patient department in Israel as someone whose English began an ended with Beowulf would be in the NHS A&E department. Eventually I became quite fluent in ivrit from a combination of evening classes and learning on the job. Although to begin with my chat up line on first (and usually last) dates with Israeli nurses was limited to polite enquiry as to the regularity of their bowel and menstrual function. With even greater experience and fluency I ventured into the territory of urinary frequency and abdominal cramps. I also was in deep trouble in the operating theatre because the words for scissors, trousers and spectacles sounded almost alike to my untrained ear. Imagine asking for a sharp pair of trousers when trying to cut through dense fibrous tissue in a case of diverticulitis! Joking aside this experience taught me what it must be like to be a new immigrant in the UK from the Indian subcontinent who suffer humiliations and ridicule because of their failure to master the English language. This must have been how my Yiddish speaking grandparents felt 100 years ago.
Eventually I was posted to a large community hospital in Afula serving the Jezreal valley and caring for the needs of a mixed bunch of secular Jewish Kibbutzniks, Religious Jews from S’fad, Moslem Arabs from the local villages and Christian Arabs from Nazareth; an exotic brew of folk who were all treated with equal respect or occasionally equal rudeness! Many of the doctors were Arabs trained in Israel and there was some intermarriage on the campus.
In spite of my early difficulties I learnt much of lifelong value in the subjects of surgical techniques and human relationships. My mentor and head of department was Professor Shmuel Nissan recently in post after having been chief resident in an American teaching hospital. He was a tall, handsome and rugged character, who had been born into and old established Jewish Palestinian family, veterans of the first aliyah. A multi-cultured man, he was fluent in Arabic as well as English and Ivrit and was popular amongst the elders of some of the local Arab villages. He grew citrus fruit on his farm and raised Arab horses and was also a medical historian. He ultimately went on to become chief of surgery at the Mount Scopus branch of the Hadassah hospital in Jerusalem. He taught me how to do a real radical mastectomy the American Halsted technique [ see chapter xxx].
Apart from learning the skills of elective surgery I had my share of emergency work. Being essentially a rural community I remember a number of grizzly accidents with tractors. More important than this was my modest yet informative introduction into the management of gunshot wounds. Although 1963-65 was a relatively peaceful time in the history of Israel there were still feddayin raids and sniper fire from the Golan hights, aimed at farmers in the fertile Beit Shan valley below. There was one extraordinary incident when I had to deal with two soldiers shot with one bullet as they patrolled the border. The sniper had managed to pierce the hand of the nearest and the shoulder of the second as they rode together in a comradely pose. On that occasion I had to give evidence to the blue berets of the UN soldiers monitoring the peace. There were hundreds of such incidents each year.
My next adventure was being sent to help out the Scottish Mission Hospital in Nazareth when their only surgeon was on sick leave. I loved the nuns who made up the nursing staff and admired their strict discipline that was in stark contrast to the laissez faire democratic attitude of the Israeli nurses in the kupat cholim (workers fund) hospital in Afula. The nuns acted as interpreters in the clinics and as surgical assistants in the theatre. By this time I was fairly proficient in the standard elective and emergencies but there was one occasion I operated with a book held up in front of me. One night a baby was born with an open spina bifida, a congenital defect where the spinal column fails to fuse over the spinal cord. With the spinal cord exposed, infection and meningitis would be inevitable and the nearest hospital with a paediatric surgeon was two hours away. Learning on the job I completed the task of mobilizing the delicate membranes around the spinal canal and succeeded in closing the defect. The baby survived but for all I knew went on to develop other complications linked to this congenital abnormality. From my current standpoint I shudder to think of my hubris at the time but I felt good about myself then and a pretty young nun made me hot chocolate before I collapsed exhausted into my bed which I sometimes shared with a pair of friendly gekkoes.
That aside my biggest adventure was being sent as deputy medical officer to the Masada dig.
Shmuel Nissan was the nephew of the President of the State of Israel, Zalman Shazan. He in turn was a close friend of Professor Yigal Yadin who was chief of staff of the IDF during the 1948 war of independence and as a second career went on to become Professor of archaeology at the Hebrew University in Jerusalem. He was in charge of the excavations of King Herod’s palace at Masada. Thus through a complex series of interactions, known in Israel as protectia I was invited to volunteer as deputy medical officer at the dig. One early morning in February 1963, I started my great adventure by bouncing along un-surfaced tracks in a military jeep driving due East from the desert town of Arad to the foot of the mountain plateau dominating the Western shore of the Dead Sea mid way between the salt works at S’dom (remember Lot’s wife?) and the oasis of Ein Gedi where King David hid in a cave from a vengeful King Saul. The archaeologist’s encampment was arranged just North of the remains of the Roman camp where Flavius Silva commanded the Roman legions in their three-year siege of the mountain fortress between 70 and 73 CE. The foot of the Roman siege ramp that rose nearly 1,000 feet to the summit separated the modern from the ancient invaders. In 73 CE the Roman foot soldiers and their siege machines stormed the fortifications at the top only to find that the 900 Jewish Zealots who had held out there following the sacking of Jerusalem and the destruction of the second temple, had committed suicide rather than fall into the hands of their enemies. As an archaeological site it was therefore of extraordinary value in providing insight into two periods of history, King Herod the Roman Viceroy and the period after the fall of the second temple.
I was housed in an army tent with three other volunteers and shared duties with a mysterious American doctor in his fifties, in a field hospital tent. Each morning before dawn we mounted to the summit up the Roman ramp and gazed in awe as the sun rose over the mountains Moab in Jordan across the early mist rising from the Dead Sea, then glancing down a 1,000 foot vertical drop to the salt plains below. Fortunately my medical skills were seldom called upon and I spent most of the time in charge of a small team digging out the debris of nearly two millennia from between the casement walls erected by King Herod to guard his Eastern flank. Our interest was in discovering the domestic details of the life of the zealots who set up home in these quarters. Two of the team dug and filled the buckets, I emptied the buckets into a large sieve held and shaken by another two volunteers. As they sieved the rubble and sand I looked for artefacts before the remaining debris was tipped over the edge of the cliff face. This way we found roman pottery shards and glassware shimmering with a fluorescent light in the strong sunshine, miraculously surviving from the time of Christ. Once we had cleared the bulk of the debris we began the careful task of cleaning the floor and searching for the clues of day -to -day life. I personally uncovered a cooking hearth by following down a trail of soot staining the junction of two stone walls. Hidden under a flag-stone making up the hearth I uncovered a rotting woven sack containing a congealed mass of bright blue discs. I watched with fascination as one of the professional archaeologists in the camp treated the find with dilute acetic acid following which the long hidden copper coinage revealed itself as new. The faces of the coins showed the chalice and the pomegranates marking them out as 73CE. So I found myself handling the loose change of a Jewish mother who had perished 1900 years earlier. The hairs stood up on the nape of my neck and one of the coins “stuck to the palm of my hand” serving as a lucky charm when I sat my exams to become a fellow of the Royal College of Surgeons in 1965.
The other moving experience for me was the celebration of the Jewish New Year for trees. Here we planted palm and myrtle in this long barren place that had once supported 900 souls for over three years and here we prayed in the first synagogue to be built after the destruction of the second temple.
For recreation we would climb down the precipitous snake path that wound down the Eastern escarpment and go off on rambles to explore the region of Ein Geddi or follow the encircling siege walls built by the Romans and still visible to all.
In the evening we would have lectures from the archaeologists including a memorable one by Professor Yadin himself, describing the finding of the Bar- Kochba caves just South of Qumran. Other evenings I would gather with my senior colleague and two lady friends for Turkish coffee and gossip in the field hospital. I could deduce nothing about the training or provenance of this American doctor but as we packed up to leave a month later he gave me an address just outside Florence suggesting we met up on my return to England.
A year later I found myself in Italy having landed at the Port of Rome en route home. A minor detour to Florence, lead me to the gate in the high wall protecting Villa Marcellio Fincino in Fiesoli. I later learnt that Fincino was one of the leading lights of the Italian renaissance. I was surprised to be shown into sumptuous gardens by a liveried servant who conducted me to his master sitting on the terrace of the most beautiful 16thC palace you can imagine. My host, the mysterious American doctor, owned a chain of private hospitals in the USA and according to his story was in hiding from hit men hired by his estranged wife. After a few days of luxury, living the life of a Florentine prince, I returned to England to pick up my career again and search for a wife.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
